The Curse of the Cat People (1944)
Directed by Gunther von Fritsch and Robert WiseRegular. Starring Simone Simon, Kent Smith, Jane Randolph, Ann Carter.

Happy holidays! Our festive special this year focuses on The Curse of the Cat People (1944), directed by Gunther von Fritsch and Robert Wise (of Star Trek: The Motion Picture and The Haunting fame), and produced by Val Lewton for RKO – a sequel that daringly abandons the horror conventions of its predecessor in favour of an atmospheric, psychological fairy-tale. The story follows young Amy Reed (Ann Carter), the sensitive and lonely daughter of Oliver Reed (Kent Smith) and Alice (Jane Randolph), whose imaginary friend manifests in the form of the serene and spectral Irena (Simone Simon), the tragic figure from Cat People (1942). With its expressionistic visuals, gentle pacing, and Lewton’s characteristically suggestive storytelling, should this film finally be released from the Movie Oubliette to flourish like Amy finding a true festive friend, or left to linger in the shadows like the fading spirits of Christmas past? Find out!
Did we set it free?
Make your call to reveal our verdict, our star rating out of five and our full review.
Skip the guess and read the review
VerdictSet free
Lars Henriks suggested this Christmas special, then fell ill before recording, so we watched it as a double bill with Cat People. Get well soon, Lars.
Val Lewton's Cat People was a cheap, shadowy hit for RKO, so the studio demanded a sequel and handed him the title. He made a children's Christmas fantasy instead. Oliver (Kent Smith) is now married to Alice (Jane Randolph), and their dreamy young daughter Amy (Ann Carter) has no friends and posts her party invitations in a hollow tree. Wishing on a ring thrown from the window of a creepy old house, she conjures a friend, who turns out to be Oliver's dead first wife, Irena (Simone Simon), dressed like a fairy-tale princess. Next door, faded actress Julia Farren insists her own grown daughter Barbara is an impostor.
There are no cat people, and very little curse. What there is turns out deeper and darker than it first appears: a father who punishes his daughter for her imagination, a daughter disowned by her mother, and a child facing death for the first time. Robert Wise took over in his directing debut when von Fritsch fell behind schedule, and the scenes in the Farren house look forward to The Haunting. Mrs Farren's telling of the Legend of Sleepy Hollow, with hooves turning into a car engine, is terrifying. Nicholas Musuraca's lighting transforms a studio garden into a glittering winter wonderland, the snow is reportedly cornflakes, and Roy Webb's score is pure Disney. A reshot ending swapped proof of the supernatural for redemption. Simone Simon later joked that she had to look beautiful because she had nothing to do.
Watched on its own terms, it's a gem. We both set it free, and so did 80 per cent of the patrons.
I think it's not sickly sweet as a Christmas movie, which is refreshing because a lot of Christmas movies are disgusting.
Dan So I think it's an undiscovered gem. I think it's lovely.
Conrad
Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.



