← The archive
Episode No.075

Toys (1992)

with Jonathan McIntosh

Directed by Barry Levinson. Starring Robin Williams, Michael Gambon, Joan Cusack, Robin Wright.

FantasyGuest: Jonathan McIntosh (Critics & Creators)
Toys (with Jonathan McIntosh)

19 April 2021 · 1:07:37

Jonathan McIntosh, creator of the Pop Culture Detective Agency, joins us to explore Barry Levinson's 1992 fantasy/comedy Toys, which features Robin Williams as the childlike son of an eccentric toymaker, Joan Cusack as his manic pixie sister, Robin Wright as his manic pixie love interest, Michael Gambon as his militaristic uncle and LL Cool J as his camouflage-obsessed cousin. This modern fable about the incursion of the military industrial complex into the sacred innocence of childhood imagination has wildly surrealistic visuals and an inventive soundtrack from legendary composer Hans Zimmer and legendary pop producer Trevor Horn, but does it bear up to scrutiny almost 30 years later? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictThrown back

Jonathan McIntosh of Pop Culture Detective handed us Barry Levinson's surrealist toy-factory satire, and it handed us a migraine.

Robin Williams is Leslie, heir to a whimsical toy empire that his uncle, a general played by Michael Gambon, turns into a weapons plant churning out remote-controlled war machines. Here is the strange part: it was right. Kids piloting drones from games consoles, the military recruiting through video games, all of it now looks less like satire and more like a forecast.

The production design, drunk on Magritte, is genuinely remarkable, and LL Cool J's camouflage gags are the closest thing to consistent comedy. Joan Cusack's Alsatia turns out to be a robot, which explains less than you'd hope. The problem sits in the middle of every frame. Williams is, and we say this with love, not funny here, and Jonathan spent the runtime picturing a better film without him, with the two women as the leads. Dan suffered acute whimsy overload.

Conrad found one teddy bear moment bizarrely disturbing and touching, then threw it back anyway. Jonathan would free it as a curiosity, but he was outvoted. A film that isn't sure what it is, and very confident about it.

  • So much whimsy... I couldn't handle the whimsy. Whimsy overload.
    Dan
  • Can I say something quite daring...? He's not funny in this movie.
    Conrad
  • I was having fun imagining what this movie would be like if Robin Williams just wasn't in it... I think it would be a better movie.
    Jonathan McIntosh

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.