← The archive
Episode No.113

Practical Magic (1998)

with Lotta Losten

Directed by Griffin Dunne. Starring Sandra Bullock, Nicole Kidman, Stockard Channing, Dianne Wiest.

FantasyGuest: Lotta Losten (Filmmakers)
Practical Magic (with Lotta Losten)

17 October 2022 · 1:09:51

Happy spooky season! Actor and producer Lotta Losten makes a welcome return to the oubliette for our Halloween Special and weaves some Practical Magic on us! This bewitching rom-com, starring Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman as the enchanting Owens sisters, failed to cast a spell on the box office when it was released during this week 24 years ago (!), but has found a special place in the hearts of many viewers since. Should it be given a broomstick and allowed to soar off the roof this Halloween, or should it be banished from the world like a warty toad? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

Actor, producer and film photographer Lotta Losten brought us a Halloween pick she found repetitive as a teenager and has since grown to love.

Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman are Sally and Gillian Owens, sisters from a line of witches cursed so that any man who loves them dies young, raised by their aunts (Stockard Channing and Dianne Wiest) in a small Massachusetts town that shuns them. Sally tries to live without magic; Gillian runs off with Goran Višnjić's abusive Jimmy Angelov, whom the sisters accidentally kill, resurrect, kill again and bury under the roses, until his spirit possesses Gillian and Aidan Quinn's investigator turns up asking questions.

It's a rom-com with witchcraft rather than a horror film, and the men are thin, but that's rather the point: this is about two sisters, and Bullock and Kidman are a joy together, from the midnight margaritas set to Harry Nilsson's 'Coconut' to a phone-tree pay-off that shouldn't work and does. Dunne's original cut was reportedly much darker, and the studio pared it back and threw out Michael Nyman's score for Alan Silvestri's chirpy, Death Becomes Her-ish one. That leaves an opening witch-hanging set to sweeping strings, and a ghost effect that hasn't aged well. Conrad wasn't sure what tone it was after and found the mechanics of Angelov's returns baffling, but could find nothing actually bad in it. It flopped, Dunne says he never got another major studio film, and it has since become a Halloween perennial.

Lotta and Dan set it free, and Conrad, unconvinced but disarmed, let it go.

  • The man doesn't save the day in this movie.
    Dan
  • On the off chance it's good, I'll let it go.
    Conrad
  • This is a movie that, to me, has gotten better.
    Lotta Losten

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.