← The archive
Episode No.178

The Secret of NIMH (1982)

with Jonathan McIntosh

Directed by Don Bluth. Starring Elizabeth Hartman, Derek Jacobi, Dom DeLuise, Arthur Malet.

FantasyGuest: Jonathan McIntosh (Critics & Creators)
The Secret of NIMH (with Jonathan McIntosh)

15 July 2025 · 1:11:49

Jonathan McIntosh, creator of the excellent Pop Culture Detective Agency, joins us to uncover The Secret of NIMH (1982). Often remembered as an example of the surprisingly dark and sombre animated children's films of the 70s and 80s, alongside Watership Down (1978) and Disney's own The Black Cauldron (1985), The Secret of NIMH lacks musical numbers, but is filled with striking imagery, glorious hand-animated effects, memorable characters and a sumptuously rich Jerry Goldsmith score. The film made an indelible mark among those 80s kids who caught it on VHS or TV back in the day. But were they scarred for life by a morbid oddity or forever elevated by a magical piece of storytelling? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

Pop Culture Detective Jonathan McIntosh, who wore out his family's VHS of this at the age of three, returned to champion a film Conrad wore out too. Dan had never seen it; his wife had, which he tells us is rare.

Don Bluth walked out of Disney with a group of animators to revive the lavish hand-drawn craft he felt the studio had abandoned, and Disney was not pleased. Mrs Brisby (Elizabeth Hartman), a widowed field mouse, must move her cinder-block home before the farmer's plough arrives, but her son Timmy has pneumonia and can't be moved. Her search for help leads past Dom DeLuise's tangle-prone crow Jeremy to John Carradine's terrifying Great Owl, and then to a colony of rats made super-intelligent by experiments at the National Institute of Mental Health, who owed her late husband a debt.

Strip it back and it's a few animals trying to escape a plough. On screen it's a horror film, intense for long stretches rather than in quick jolts. Mrs Brisby is terrified throughout and brave in every scene, a frightened mother rather than an action hero. The background paintings, backlit cels and glowing amulet still look astonishing, and Jerry Goldsmith, scoring his first animated film, refused to write anything cute. Derek Jacobi's Nicodemus adds gravitas; Auntie Shrew, set up as comic relief, turns out to be the one who stops the plough. Fans of Robert C. O'Brien's novel resent the magic amulet, and the book's Frisby became Brisby after the voices were recorded, reportedly over Wham-O's trademark, with every mention spliced by hand.

Jonathan would put it in the Hall of Fame, Conrad calls it a masterpiece, Dan found it a warm hug of a film, and the patrons agreed.

  • It's cold and wet outside. Let's put on The Secret of NIMH. And it feels like a warm hug.
    Dan
  • There are many things about the 80s that scarred me, but, you know, flights of fancy and art and imagination were not one of them.
    Conrad
  • I think it's one of the great gems of not only animation, but filmmaking in general. So I think it belongs in the Hall of Fame, for sure.
    Jonathan McIntosh

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.