← The archive
Episode No.122

Dungeons and Dragons (2000)

with Michael French

Directed by Courtney Solomon. Starring Justin Whalin, Marlon Wayans, Jeremy Irons, Zoe McLellan.

FantasyGuest: Michael French (Critics & Creators)
Dungeons and Dragons (with Michael French)

20 March 2023 · 1:07:49

A new Dungeons and Dragons movie arrives in theatres this month, so we thought we'd take a look back at the very first attempt to bring the beloved role-playing phenomenon to the screen. As two first-level novices, Dan and Conrad needed an expert Dungeon Master to guide them through this early 2000s CGI-fest, so the sage-like Michael French of RetroBlasting joins them. At least, he does until his Internet took pity and set him free from the spectacle of PlayStation 1 cut-screen establishing shots, Jeremy Irons devouring the scenery and spitting it venomously back out, and evil henchmen in frosty blue lipstick. The fantasy extravaganza directed by first-time helmer Courtney Solomon, featuring Justin Whalin, Marlon Wayans, Thora Birch, Zoe McLellan and Kristen Wilson is a much-maligned box office disaster, but is it a powerful gem just waiting to be rediscovered? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictThrown back

Retroblasting's Michael French saw this as a film student at a shopping-centre cinema near Syracuse University and had avoided it for 23 years, so naturally we made him fetch it.

Jeremy Irons's scheming mage Profion wants a sceptre that controls red dragons so he can topple Thora Birch's young Empress of Izmer, and two thieves, Justin Whalin's Ridley and Marlon Wayans's Snails, get swept up in the race to find it. Michael pointed out the basic problem with adapting a game that lives in its players' heads. Director Courtney Solomon, a superfan who reportedly spent a decade getting it made, compounds it by stitching together other franchises' greatest hits: a Phantom Menace council, a cantina brawl, a garbage-chute escape, a Raiders booby-trap run that turns into an episode of The Crystal Maze, Richard O'Brien and all, and a Fellowship-style healing among elves.

Everyone overacts, but Irons, who has reportedly said he took the job to pay for renovating his castle, and Bruce Payne's blue-lipsticked Damodar leave William Shatner in the dust. A reported $45 million, stretched further by shooting in Prague, buys some handsome interiors and decent orc prosthetics, but the CGI dragons and swooping establishing shots look like PlayStation cut scenes. The best effect is a rug that swallows Snails, made from porridge oats that, according to the effects supervisor, kept fermenting. Ridley's reason for hating mages ended up among the deleted scenes, Snails dies mid-film, and the ending makes no sense. Michael's connection gave out before the verdict, which may have been a mercy.

We threw it back, and so did every voting patron, a first.

  • I would say out of all the movies that we've done on the podcast, this might be the worst movie we've ever covered.
    Dan
  • I wouldn't wish this on my worst enemy. I think this is quite safe back in the Oubliette.
    Conrad
  • There are five, maybe six decisions in my life that I really wish I could get in a DeLorean and take back. This one is probably number four or five.
    Michael French

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.