← The archive
Episode No.153

Erik the Viking (1989)

with Michael French

Directed by Terry Jones. Starring Tim RobbinsRegular, Mickey Rooney, Eartha Kitt, Terry Jones.

FantasyGuest: Michael French (Critics & Creators)
Erik the Viking (with Michael French)

1 July 2024 · 1:13:07

Michael French of RetroBlasting joins us on a quest to Valhalla with Erik the Viking (1989) – Monty Python alumni Terry Jones' fantasy film starring Tim Robbins, Samantha Bond, Imogen Stubbs, Eartha Kitt, Mickey Rooney and John Cleese. This is the second historical adventure film from ex-Pythons we've covered this year that attempts to avoid treading on the comedy troupe's large coat-tails and trips rather spectacularly, stumbling out of the box office top 20 in under a week with less than $2 million on a $15 million budget. But is Erik's earnest quest to end the violent days of Ragnorok an overlooked rib-tickling masterwork or a tedious misfire? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

Retroblasting's Michael French went down into the Oubliette and came back with Terry Jones's Viking comedy. All three of us had seen it as kids, and none of us remembered more than a scene. Michael reckons that's the film's one magic power: it forgets itself.

Tim Robbins is Erik, a Viking who can't bring himself to rape or pillage, haunted by Helga (Samantha Bond), killed in the opening raid where he lost his nerve. He leads his village to find Hy-Brasil and a magic horn that will wake the gods and end the age of Ragnarok, pursued by John Cleese's warlord Halfdan the Black, who profits from endless war. On the way they meet Imogen Stubbs's lovestruck Princess Aud, while Freddie Jones's missionary fails to see any of the Norse magic around him.

The production is lovely. Hy-Brasil's sinking was shot full-size in Malta, there's a proper in-camera sea dragon, and the voyage over the edge of the world to Asgard is magical, chiefly because nobody makes a joke during it. Everywhere else the gags are laboured to death, the scenes don't join up, and the fight scenes have no energy. Cleese, playing Halfdan as a bored merchant banker, is the only one who lands, and his single, weary "What?" is the funniest line in the film.

Jones never solved the pacing: the 107-minute theatrical cut eventually became the 75-minute Director's Son's Cut, which is no better.

Michael and Conrad threw it back. Dan, who loved the quest and hated the comedy, sided with the patrons, who voted 75 to 25 to free it. The coin landed on tails, so it has been evicted from the one place it was safe.

  • It is a movie that is in itself an oubliette. Terry Jones has managed to make a movie that forgets itself.
    Michael French
  • I hated the comedy. I wanted all of that just taken out of the movie. But I did like the premise.
    Dan
  • It's like your uncle who's had a few too many drinks at a family gathering trying to be funny and laboring it too long.
    Conrad

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.