Batman Returns (1992)
with Melinda Mock and Michael French
Directed by Tim Burton. Starring Michael Keaton, Danny DeVito, Michelle Pfeiffer, Christopher Walken.

Melinda Mock and Michael French of RetroBlasting fame answered our bat signal at the eleventh hour to join us for this special festive episode after our original guest had to drop out. And boy, are we glad they did! Yes, it's a bit cheeky of us to cover Tim Burton's snowy sequel to his blockbusting hit Batman (1989) on Movie Oubliette. It's dubious to claim it has been overlooked in the years since, but it was certainly a box office disappointment for Warner Bros. when it debuted in 1992. Adjusted for inflation, it earned $420 million less than the original, and is the second-lowest-grossing live action Batman movie, beaten only by Batman and Robin.
But is this dark and kinky sequel, in which Batman appears for only 23 minutes, a freaky festive classic? Or a gloomy gothic mess?
Did we set it free?
Make your call to reveal our verdict, our star rating out of five and our full review.
Skip the guess and read the review
VerdictSet free
Hardly forgotten, we admit, though adjusted for inflation it's the second-least successful live-action Batman, beaten only by Batman & Robin. When our scheduled guest dropped out, Retroblasting's Melinda Mock and Michael French swooped in for our Christmas special.
Burton barely bothers with Batman, who doesn't get a line for half an hour. The film belongs to its freaks. Danny DeVito's Penguin, abandoned in the sewers by Paul Reubens, is a black-oil-drooling, fish-gnawing horror who runs for mayor while planning to murder Gotham's firstborn. Christopher Walken plays the crooked tycoon Max Shreck. Then there's Michelle Pfeiffer's Selina Kyle, a mousy secretary pushed out of a window, revived by cats and stitched into a PVC catsuit, cracking a bullwhip she learned to use for real.
Melinda calls it the Temple of Doom of Batman films, dark enough to send the studio running to Batman Forever, which outgrossed it. Michael rates it the best Batman ever made, not least for its many incinerated clowns. Dan calls it his favourite childhood film. All three adore Pfeiffer's Catwoman, a study in long-suppressed rage. Conrad loves her too, along with Danny Elfman's operatic score, his favourite Elfman. He finds the rest tedious and studio-bound: a speech in the snowy square, a clown attack, repeat, and a Penguin he finds simply repellent. Everyone relishes how much kink and cruelty slipped into a McDonald's tie-in, from the cat yanked into baby Oswald's cage onwards.
Conrad was the lone voice for oblivion. 89 per cent of the patrons, in our biggest vote of the year, sided with everyone else.
Ergo, this is not only a film that should be remembered, it's the greatest Batman movie of all time.
Michael French This movie in the Batman series of films is the Temple of Doom of the Batman series, because it's really dark.
Melinda Mock I think this is my favorite childhood movie of all time, looking back on it.
Dan
Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.




