← The archive
Episode No.163

Portrait of Jennie (1948)

with Amanda Jane Stern

Directed by William Dieterle. Starring Jennifer Jones, Joseph Cotten, Ethel Barrymore, Lillian Gish.

FantasyGuest: Amanda Jane Stern (Critics & Creators)
Portrait of Jennie (with Amanda Jane Stern)

18 November 2024 · 1:18:03

Actor, writer and producer Amanda Jane Stern – whose psychosexual thriller Perfectly Good Moment has launched on Tubi this month – joins us to discuss David O. Selznick's production of Portrait of Jennie. Based on a popular novella by Robert Nathan that Ray Bradbury said "touched and frightened" him, the romantic fantasy won an Oscar for Best Special Effects in 1948, but was not a success. Set in depression-era New York, it starred Jennifer Jones as the titular Jennie, an enigmatic young woman who inspires an impoverished painter, played by Joseph Cotton. The film is well regarded among those who remember it or have rediscovered it, but it's not easy to come by on streaming services or physical media. Unless you stumble upon it on Youtube, of course. But does it deserve to escape the oubliette and be immortalised? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

Our oldest main-feed film yet, brought by filmmaker and classic-cinema enthusiast Amanda Jane Stern, who saw it aged about six and spent years convinced she'd dreamt it.

In Depression-era New York, struggling painter Eben Adams (Joseph Cotten) meets Jennie (Jennifer Jones), a girl who talks about decades-old events as if they were current, then vanishes. Each time she reappears she is older, and Eben's portraits of her make his name. Is she a ghost, a time traveller, or, as Amanda suggests, versions of a girl slipping between timelines? A multiverse, in 1948.

David O. Selznick bought Robert Nathan's novella as a vehicle for Jones, his girlfriend, and cast Cotten partly because he trusted him with her. Selznick micromanaged everything, by Cotten's account once running across a frozen lake mid-take to announce he finally understood the novel. It cost a reported $4 million, more than Gone with the Wind, and flopped. The plot is feather-light and leans on a romance between two people who barely share the screen, and the age dynamic sits awkwardly now. But it's spellbinding to look at. Joseph H. August shot scenes through canvas so they resemble paintings and died shortly after finishing the storm sequence, and the film switches to green tint and then a final Technicolor shot. There's real location work at the Cloisters and in Central Park, and a lovely gallery of character parts, from Ethel Barrymore's wry art dealer to Lillian Gish's nun. Dimitri Tiomkin's Debussy-based score is wall-to-wall, and Selznick tried to sue over a pop song called Portrait of Jennie, which Nat King Cole turned into a standard.

Hosts, guest and every patron set it free.

  • I find it such a fascinating time capsule of 1940s cinema with some actors I love and just seeing old New York City where I live.
    Amanda Jane Stern
  • I'm shocked that this movie was made in 1948. There's so much sort of depth and complexity and experimental sort of filmmaking as well.
    Dan
  • The movie is just stunning to look at. It really is quite spellbinding.
    Conrad

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.