← The archive
Episode No.201

Supergirl (1984)

with Amanda Jane Stern

Directed by Jeannot SzwarcRegular. Starring Helen Slater, Faye Dunaway, Peter O'Toole, Mia Farrow.

Sci-fiFantasyGuest: Amanda Jane Stern (Critics & Creators)
Supergirl (1984) (with Amanda Jane Stern)

23 June 2026 · 1:20:28

Hollywood's penchant for revisiting failed franchises this summer has awakened a number of 80s oddities in the oubliette! This time, Amanda Jane Stern joins us to revisit the Salkinds' 1984 attempt at a Superman spin-off: Supergirl, featuring Helen Slater as Kara Zor-El/Linda Lee, Faye Dunaway as the witchy Selena, and Peter O’Toole, Mia Farrow, Marc McClure, and others filling out a very British, very prestige-flavoured comic-book fever dream. Much like Masters of the Universe (1987), it's a film about a missing macguffin, a displaced hero from an alien world navigating 80s America, and the familiar fantasy of inherited power being folded into an Americana quest narrative – all while trying to look serious enough to justify its budget and strange enough to justify its existence. Should Supergirl be set free to soar into heroism, or should it be locked away in the Phantom Zone? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictThrown back

With a new Supergirl on the way, Amanda Jane Stern joined us for the third time. It was a first watch for her. We both remembered it from childhood, without much affection.

The power source of Argo City, a floating Kryptonian enclave, is a spinning softball called the Omegahedron, and Peter O'Toole lets it fly out of a window. Kara (Helen Slater) follows it to Earth. Instead of looking for it, she enrols at a girls' boarding school as Linda Lee and shares a room with Lucy Lane. The Omegahedron lands in the dip at a picnic held by Selena (Faye Dunaway), a would-be witch who could use it to conquer the world and decides to win over a hunky landscape gardener (Hart Bochner) instead.

The Salkinds reportedly spent about $35 million, and much of it seems to have gone on a fake Illinois town built at Pinewood. The stakes barely rise above two women fighting over a man neither of them really wants. The romance between a schoolgirl and a grown man is uncomfortable, and coincidences pile up: Selena's warlock ex (Peter Cook) is also Kara's maths teacher. The first proper rescue, from a runaway bulldozer, arrives after an hour and goes on forever. Slater is genuinely good, poised and graceful on the new flying rig, and Dunaway and Brenda Vaccaro have a camp, possibly queer-coded spark that deserved its own film. Jerry Goldsmith's score drowns in whooshing synths, and Kara's exit from the lake was, by Dan's account, a cardboard cut-out on a wire. The script is by David Odell, who went on to write Masters of the Universe.

All three of us threw it back. To our surprise the patrons leaned the other way, though few of their comments backed it up, and we overruled them.

  • It feels so small scale and not fully committed to any of its tones.
    Conrad
  • I do feel like Helen Slater is the best part of this movie.
    Dan
  • It's never campy enough. It's never funny enough. It makes no sense.
    Amanda Jane Stern

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.