Santa Claus: The Movie (1985)
with Simon Barber
Directed by Jeannot SzwarcRegular. Starring Dudley Moore, John LithgowRegular, David Huddleston, Burgess Meredith.

Simon Barber, co-host of the Sodajerker on Songwriting podcast, joins us for our festive finale to 2022: and it's a doozy! The producing team behind the original Superman: The Movie (1978), its first two sequels and the spin-off Supergirl (1984) turned their attention to another origin story for a much-loved supernatural hero in 1985, and brought us Santa Claus: The Movie. Featuring Dudley Moore as a cheery elf determined to modernise the North Pole, David Huddlestone as the titular jolly gift-giver and scenery-munching John Lithgow as the nefarious business tycoon B.Z., the film has everything you could ever want in seasonal family adventure. Highlights include abducting homeless children to take them on flying reindeer joyrides with dangerous manoeuvres near the Twin Towers in Manhattan, John Lithgow screaming "FOR FREE?!!" and turning beetroot red when Dudley Moore attempts to explain the act of giving a gift, and Aled Jones singing on a glorious soundtrack by Henry Mancini. But is it the gift that keeps on giving, or is it failed super-dooper looper? Find out!
Did we set it free?
Make your call to reveal our verdict, our star rating out of five and our full review.
Skip the guess and read the review
VerdictSet free
Simon Barber of Birmingham City University and the Sodajerker on Songwriting podcast first saw this at the ABC on Lime Street in Liverpool in 1985, then, like a generation of Brits, on telly every Christmas Eve.
Alexander and Ilya Salkind, fresh from Superman, give us two films for the price of one. The first is an earnest origin story in which woodcutter Claus (David Huddleston) and his wife (Judy Cornwell) are rescued from a blizzard by elves and installed at the North Pole by Burgess Meredith's ancient, extravagantly bearded elder. The second drops into 1980s New York, where Dudley Moore's elf Patch, shamed after his production line misfires, falls in with John Lithgow's toy tycoon B.Z., a crook who devours the scenery and steals the film.
Its anti-commercialism message arrives amid wall-to-wall Coca-Cola and McDonald's product placement. The craft is real: Arthur Ibbetson's photography, Derek Meddings' miniatures, a Henry Mancini score with Leslie Bricusse lyrics and Aled Jones on vocals, and reindeer both animatronic and real. Then the Super Duper Looper dive-bombs past the World Trade Center, the elf puns reach nine, and the ending, with an orphan whisked off to the Pole for keeps, looked to us a lot like child abduction. Patch was reportedly first conceived as 'Scratch', a Lucifer figure, with B.Z. a nod to Beelzebub, and John Carpenter was reportedly offered the film first. It reportedly cost around $50 million including prints and advertising and grossed $23.7 million, flopping in the US while becoming a fixture here. Simon loves to hate it, Dan found it magical and Conrad adores it despite himself. Set free.
It's definitely magical. It's got a lot of humor.
Dan The whole thing is just a shoddy, gaudy monstrosity. But for some reason, I absolutely love it.
Conrad It needs to be taken out of the Oubliette every Christmas Eve and played on British television, so we have to keep it.
Simon Barber
Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.





