← The archive
Episode No.175

The Tall Man (2012)

Directed by Pascal Laugier. Starring Jessica Biel, Jodelle Ferland, Stephen McHattie, William B. Davis.

Horror
The Tall Man

3 June 2025 · 1:06:22

Pascal Laugier's follow-up to Martyrs (2008) is a Canadian-French horror/thriller, set in a small, poverty-stricken town in Washington where local nurse Julia (Jessica Biel) gets caught up in a string of child abductions, which the townsfolk blame on a legendary boogeyman figure, The Tall Man (2012). The result is a twisty, turny tale full of surprises and stinger-highlighted jump scares. But is it an underrated classic of sociological terror or a muddle of deceptive plot contrivances? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictThrown back

Dan's pick, offered with a warning that it was flawed, and Conrad's first film from the director of Martyrs, a landmark of the New French Extremity. Heavy spoilers follow, as there's no discussing it otherwise.

In the dying mining town of Cold Rock, children keep vanishing, and the locals blame a hooded figure they call the Tall Man. Nurse Julia (Jessica Biel), apparently widowed, sees her son David snatched one night and pursues his abductor in a brutal, thrilling sequence involving a moving van, a ferocious dog and a lot of broken glass. Then the rug is pulled. Julia is the kidnapper, part of a network that steals children from poor families and rehomes them with wealthy ones, and David isn't hers.

Laugier says he was after the moral ambiguity of 70s films like Taxi Driver, and ends on Jenny (Jodelle Ferland), a willing abductee, asking the camera whether this is a good thing. The film never really interrogates it, treats Julia as a martyr and wanders close to QAnon territory. Conrad checked a claim Laugier made in interviews about a real 2007 child-smuggling case in Chad, and it didn't hold up. Worse, characters behave in ways nobody would simply to hide the twist, and the stingers and flash cuts struck Conrad as trashy. Dan argues the twist could work if the film let Julia be the villain, and enjoyed the first hour, after which almost nothing happens for 40 minutes. Biel is committed, and William B. Davis as Sheriff Chestnut raised a smile. David's enormous curly wig deserved its own credit.

We both threw it back. Roughly two thirds of the patrons wanted it freed, and we overruled them.

  • There is no tall man. The movie should be called There Is No Tall Man.
    Dan
  • This is probably the one where my final verdict has been the most obvious throughout, of every episode we've done out of 175.
    Conrad

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.