← The archive
Episode No.074

Coherence (2013)

with Brian Sheehan

Directed by James Ward Byrkit. Starring Emily Baldoni, Maury Sterling, Nicholas Brendon, Elizabeth Gracen.

HorrorSci-fiGuest: Brian Sheehan (Critics & Creators)
Coherence (with Brian Sheehan)

5 April 2021 · 1:06:10

Brian Sheehan of TV Trivia Pod joins us for a dinner party in which four couples have to contend with a comet flyby, the fracturing of reality into multiple dimensions and... just a whisper of ketamine. It's James Ward Byrkit's surreal sci-fi thriller Coherence (2013), starring Emily Baldoni, Nicolas Brendon and Nicolas Brendon's twin brother, Kelly Donovan. But is it a pioneering, low budget/high concept classic or is it a befuddling mirror universe? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

Brian Sheehan of TV Trivia Pod invited us to a dinner party on the night a comet passes overhead, and we left checking that our own doors were locked.

Eight friends gather, the power fails, and the one house still lit up down the road starts to look uncomfortably familiar. What follows was shot over five nights on a Canon 5D, with the cast largely improvising from notes slipped to them in envelopes, so nobody quite knew what anyone else was about to say. That uncertainty is the whole engine.

Emily Baldoni anchors it as Em, whose growing interest in window shopping between realities takes the film somewhere much darker than a parlour game. Glow sticks, numbered photographs and a lone black V-neck jumper become clues, and the decision to keep wandering outside proves as wise as you'd expect. Nicholas Brendon, Maury Sterling and Lorene Scafaria round out a cast that sells the paranoia without a scrap of spectacle. Dan liked it even more second time round, and Conrad reckons you could fill a whiteboard with diagrams and still be arguing at midnight. Brian admired how much they did with so little. A brilliant puzzle box on a shoestring.

  • I actually enjoyed it the second time round more than the first time round.
    Dan
  • Really? You've only got one black V-neck sweater?
    Conrad
  • I really like what they did with it on such a low budget... conceptually it is still a very entertaining, thought-provoking movie.
    Brian Sheehan

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.