I Am Not a Serial Killer (2016)
featuring Dan Wells
Directed by Billy O'Brien. Starring Max Records, Christopher Lloyd, Laura Fraser, Karl Geary.

Happy holidays! Writer Dan Wells joins us for our festive finale for the year to discuss the adaptation of his novel I Am Not a Serial Killer. The film stars Max Records as John Wayne Cleaver, a serial-killer-obsessed teenager who works in his mother's mortuary and has been diagnosed with sociopathy, and Christopher Lloyd as Bill Crowley, John's gentle old neighbour... who harbours a dark secret. When a killer terrorises John's snowbound midwestern town from Halloween to the holiday season, what begins as a hobbyist's investigation turns into a deadly game of cat-and-mouse with a monster even John struggles to understand. Can he stop the slasher before his family becomes the next target? Will he be able to keep his own dark impulses under control? And will his absentee father send him a decent gift this year? Find out!
Did we set it free?
Make your call to reveal our verdict, our star rating out of five and our full review.
Skip the guess and read the review
VerdictSet free
Our Christmas special, and a first: we talked to the author of the source novel, Dan Wells, about how Billy O'Brien's film adapted it.
Max Records is John Wayne Cleaver, a teenager in a snowbound Midwestern town who helps embalm bodies at the family mortuary, has been diagnosed as a sociopath and lives by strict rules to stop himself becoming a serial killer, just as a real one starts leaving mutilated bodies around town with organs missing. A third of the way in, the film switches genre without warning when his kindly elderly neighbour Bill Crowley (Christopher Lloyd, in a rare meaty role) turns out to be something inhuman, harvesting body parts to keep himself going for the sake of his beloved wife.
Shot on grainy 16mm, it has the feel of a 70s indie, Romero's Martin crossed with the deadpan humour of Fargo, and its real strength is the people: John's exhausted, loving mother (Laura Fraser), his long-suffering sister, his dim but sweet friend Max, and the Crowleys' tender marriage. Wells told us O'Brien changed his ending and added a community dance before one killing, and he now thinks the film was right on both counts. Toby Froud, the baby from Labyrinth, designed the monster, all practical, though its one full reveal threw some viewers. Adrian Johnston's spare score of organ and nagging woodwind is well placed, and John's cardboard-box speech to a bully is chilling. Conrad, who recommended it, calls it a festive horror gem; Dan loved it.
The patrons voted roughly 60–40 to throw it back, and for the second time this year we overruled them.
It's just got a good balance of everything I want in a movie.
Dan I think this is a real festive horror gem that not a lot of people might have heard of.
Conrad As much as it's a horror novel and it's about a monster that steals body parts and things, more than that, at least for me, it's a story about human relationships.
Dan Wells
Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.




