The Hole (2009)
Directed by Joe DanteRegular. Starring Chris Massoglia, Haley Bennett, Nathan Gamble, Bruce Dern.

Dan and Conrad gaze long into the oubliette, and 'The Hole' gazes back at them! It all gets a bit meta as they revisit Joe Dante's sprightly 3D horror extravaganza, which disappeared without a trace in 2009. Do they conquer their worst fears?
Did we set it free?
Make your call to reveal our verdict, our star rating out of five and our full review.
Skip the guess and read the review
VerdictThrown back
Two brothers move into a new house, find a bottomless hole boarded up in the basement, and unboard it, because of course they do, unleashing manifestations of each character's specific fears. It's Joe Dante's first film in years, and Conrad picked it out of real affection for his older work, hoping for a return to Gremlins-era form. There are flickers of it: the jester clown sequence in particular has some of the old Dante mischief, and the film clearly knows how to stage a scare for an audience that's never seen one before. It was also shot for 3D, and it shows in ways that don't survive the flat transfer, with compositions that read as empty or oddly staged in two dimensions.
Neither of us could get past how derivative the rest of it feels, or how thin the character work is. There's real horror-movie-shaped scaffolding here without much holding it up, and a lead performance that never gives you a reason to worry about the two brothers or the father's presence looming over the story. As an introduction to horror for an eight-year-old, this might genuinely work. As a film for either of us, it doesn't. We agreed fast, and Conrad in particular felt the sting of picking a personal favourite that didn't hold up on rewatch.
It was just overall so derivative and cheesy and cliché. For a horror fan, I'm entirely the wrong audience for this film. As an introduction to horror for a young person, though, it's actually pretty good.
Dan I think in all good conscience, the end result does not add up to the sum of its many recycled parts. I wanted it to be a different movie. I remembered it as being a different movie. It's not that movie.
Conrad
Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.




