← The archive
Episode No.136

Solomon Kane (2009)

Directed by Michael J. Bassett. Starring James Purefoy, Max von Sydow, Rachel Hurd-Wood, Pete Postlethwaite.

Fantasy
Solomon Kane

2 October 2023 · 1:13:38

In this Patron's Choice episode, we're venturing into the territory of sword and sorcery master Robert E. Howard's Solomon Kane (2009), M. J. Bassett's largely forgotten action adventure film starring James Purefoy as the brutal privateer turned Puritan avenger on a quest to rescue a young pilgrim girl from an evil sorcerer. This one vanished without a trace after a bungled release in the US, where it was held up by legal issues, so few genre fans had a chance to witness its glorious locations, gritty tone, bone crunching action and stunning stunts on the big screen. But does it stand the test of time, or is it an unremarkable addition to the post-Lord-of-the-Rings high fantasy boom of the noughties? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

Patron Anthony nominated this, the roulette wheel picked it, and only Dan had seen it before.

Robert E. Howard, creator of Conan, introduced his Puritan swordsman in Weird Tales in 1928, and director Michael J. Bassett (now M.J. Bassett) gives him the origin story the pulps never did. James Purefoy's Kane begins as a ruthless privateer, meets the Devil's Reaper in a North African fortress, learns his soul is damned and renounces violence in a monastery. Then he falls in with a family of pilgrims (Pete Postlethwaite, Alice Krige and Rachel Hurd-Wood as their daughter Meredith) just as a sorcerer's masked overlord and his zombified followers ravage the land, and the slaughter that follows, a child included, drives him back to the sword.

Bassett says she told her cast to ignore the genre and play the period straight, and it shows: no quips, no PVC, everyone filthy, the Czech landscapes real and Dan Laustsen's photography handsome. Purefoy, who reportedly did most of his own stunts, is a convincingly haunted hero, Max von Sydow makes the most of what was reportedly two days' work, Patrick Tatopoulos's ghouls and towering Reaper are terrific, and a stuntman sword-fights while fully ablaze for two-minute takes. It's a beat-for-beat hero's journey with a crucifixion thrown in, Dan found the religion a touch preachy, the masked villain's identity is no great surprise, and Jason Flemyng's sorcerer barely appears. Rights wrangles reportedly held up its US release until 2012, and the planned trilogy never happened. Conrad called it a lost gem, Dan agreed, and so did every patron. Set free.

  • I think it's a very well-made film. Very well-made. And I think it's worth a watch.
    Dan
  • Anthony has done exactly what we wanted to do on this podcast, which is find a gem that just got lost.
    Conrad

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.