Lady in the Water (2006)
Directed by M. Night Shyamalan. Starring Paul Giamatti, Bryce Dallas Howard, Jeffrey Wright, Bob BalabanRegular.

Dan and Conrad were spelunking in the oubliette's indoor pool and resurfaced M. Night Shyamalan's Lady in the Water (2006), a fairy tale for adults starring Paul Giamatti as a melancholy caretaker in an apartment building who discovers a 'narf' in the community swimming pool. That might sound like a euphemism for something revolting, but it turns out to be an ethereal nymph-like creature played by Bryce Dallas Howard, whose mission is to inspire a great writer to create a work that will change the world before she is ravaged by magical wolves called 'scrunts'. In a questionable move, the director casts himself in the role of the inspirational writer, and various fantasy hijinks ensue. The film is widely regarded as part of Shyamalan's precipitous downfall after his smash hit The Sixth Sense (1999), but is it as bad as people think, or does it deserve a re-evaluation? Find out!
Did we set it free?
Make your call to reveal our verdict, our star rating out of five and our full review.
Skip the guess and read the review
VerdictThrown back
Dan gave up on Shyamalan around The Happening, so this was his first look at the film that marked the start of the slide, down to 25% on Rotten Tomatoes from The Village's 43%.
Paul Giamatti's Cleveland Heep, superintendent of a Philadelphia apartment block, finds Story (Bryce Dallas Howard), a narf or sea nymph, living under the swimming pool. She has come to inspire a writer whose book will change the world, and a grass-covered wolf called a scrunt wants her dead. Saving her means working out which residents fit the roles in a bedtime myth, explained piecemeal by a Korean mother via her exasperated daughter.
Shyamalan casts himself as the visionary writer, who learns his book will get him killed and writes it anyway, then has Bob Balaban's film critic mauled to death while explaining why he won't be. Awkwardly for Shyamalan, the critic is right about almost everything. The mythology seems invented on the spot, each problem arriving just as someone explains its solution, and the residents are plot devices rather than people. Yet everything around the script is first-rate: Christopher Doyle's photography, a full-size apartment complex built for the film, Crash McCreery's creature designs (whose practical work we suspect was largely painted over with CGI), and a gorgeous James Newton Howard score. Giamatti's apology to his dead family, and Howard's otherworldly Story, very nearly make it work. Conrad has a soft spot for it; Dan has rarely been so irritated by a film.
Back it goes.
I'm baffled by all the great elements of this movie coming together to produce a turd.
Dan And for a film that is a love letter to the importance of great storytelling… It's kind of ironic, isn't it? But the storytelling's really shit.
Conrad
Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.


