← The archive
Episode No.028

Ravenous (1999)

with Serge Bodnarchuk

Directed by Antonia Bird. Starring Guy Pearce, Robert Carlyle, Jeremy Davies, Jeffrey Jones.

HorrorGuest: Serge Bodnarchuk (Critics & Creators)
Ravenous (with Serge Bodnarchuk)

28 May 2019 · 1:09:29

For our first anniversary, we invite back our first ever guest – writer/director Serge Bodnarchuk. He comes in from the cold with a tall tale about Guy Pearce, Robert Carlyle and David Arquette being out there somewhere in a forgotten western/horror cannibalism movie called 'Ravenous' (1999), so Dan and Conrad follow him into the icy wilderness after obediently smothering themselves in hot sauce. Will they find it tasty or will it leave them famished?

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

We were joined this episode by our first returning guest, writer-director and video essayist Serge Bodnarchuk, who also picked the film: a horror-western in which a disgraced army captain (Guy Pearce) is exiled to a remote 1840s outpost, only to discover that eating human flesh grants an unnerving sort of strength. The production was a mess by any measure: original director Milcho Manchevski was replaced late by Antonia Bird, brought on with five days' prep in the Slovakian snow, and screenwriter Ted Griffin has admitted he ran out of ideas halfway through and simply started again. Somehow all of that shows and doesn't sink the film. The tone lurches from slapstick to gothic horror without warning, and Michael Nyman and Damon Albarn's oddly matched dual score sometimes fights the picture rather than serving it. But Guy Pearce's nearly wordless first act, the film's cannibalism-as-Manifest-Destiny metaphor, and a handful of gorgeously staged setpieces add up to something we couldn't stop thinking about, even when it wasn't quite working.

We split properly for the first time this episode: Serge and Conrad came around to the film after a rewatch, Dan never did. Since Serge picked it, his vote breaks the tie: Ravenous is freed, jumbled tone and all.

  • It's almost like the film is made up of jigsaw pieces, but they're from three separate jigsaw puzzles, and you're trying to put it together. And as hard as you try, those remaining pieces just don't quite lock into place.
    Dan
  • It's beautifully balanced with the opening scene that kicked the whole thing off: Boyd starts out in a pile of bodies unwillingly, traumatised by it, and by the end his act of heroism is to purposefully pin himself on top of a body and die like that. I love it.
    Conrad
  • Before that moment, you're worried that people are going to die horrible deaths. But once you realise there are superheroes running around, it felt like we were dealing less with characters and more with ideas.
    Serge

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.