← The archive
Episode No.159

Carnosaur (1993)

with Serge Bodnarchuk

Directed by Adam Simon. Starring Diane Ladd, Raphael Sbarge, Jennifer Runyon, Harrison Page.

HorrorSci-fiGuest: Serge Bodnarchuk (Critics & Creators)
Carnosaur (with Serge Bodnarchuk)

23 September 2024 · 1:15:49

Saurian cinema connoisseur Serge Bodnarchuk of Cold Crash Pictures joins Dan as guest co-host for a dinosaur sci-fi horror adventure from 1993. No, not that one. This is Movie Oubliette! It's the low-budget Roger Corman production Carnosaur, starring Laura Dern's mom, Diane Ladd, and Bryce Dallas Howard's uncle, Clint Howard! This adaptation of John Brosnan's novel hit 65 theatres a few weeks before Spielberg's blockbuster romped into box office history. Featuring astonishing special effects from Troll director John Carl Buechler, this alleged mockbuster is without doubt the scrappy underdog, but is it a charming creature feature that deserves to be rescued? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictThrown back

With Conrad at the Toronto International Film Festival, Dan was joined by Serge Bodnarchuk of Cold Crash Pictures, our resident dinosaur expert. Serge had stared at the box in Blockbuster as a kid, was barred by its R rating, and only caught up with it in 2021.

Roger Corman rushed this out ahead of Jurassic Park, loosely adapting John Brosnan's 1984 novel and whittling its menagerie down to two species. In a Nevada desert town, people are being shredded by something the locals insist must be a bobcat. It's a Deinonychus, hatched from the eggs of Diane Ladd's Dr Tiptree, a chicken-farm geneticist who loves dinosaurs and loathes humanity ("Mankind. When was man ever kind?").

Halfway through, the film swerves. Tiptree has also released a virus that turns women into dinosaur incubators, and she delivers her plan over several scenes intercut so badly that it seems to take days. Hazmat soldiers start gunning down everyone who tries to leave, and the ending is as bleak as they come.

It cost about $850,000 and was shot in 18 days, with most of the money spent on John Carl Buechler's creatures, including a 16-foot T. rex that weighs just 450 pounds. It looks different in every scene, often in near-total darkness. Serge thinks the real failings are basic scripting: you don't know who the hero is for 45 minutes. Roger Ebert named it the worst film of 1993. The sheriff's showdown, ending with a sickle claw that would have to be S-shaped, and a hatchling cracked open over the sheriff's omelette are highlights.

Serge set it free for the brave 10 per cent. Dan threw it back, the patrons split 50–50, and the coin landed on tails.

  • I think 90% of the human beings on planet Earth will get nothing from this movie. But I think the other 10%, I think this is a good movie to recommend to the right audience.
    Serge Bodnarchuk
  • I would love to see a full-blown, terrifying dinosaur horror. And it does try, but I don't think it delivers quite.
    Dan

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.