The Exorcist prequels (2004)
with Serge Bodnarchuk
Directed by Renny Harlin and Paul Schrader. Starring Stellan Skarsgård, Izabella Scorupco, James D'Arcy, Ralph Brown.

Serge Bodnarchuk of Cold Crash Pictures joins us for a spooky season double-whammy spectacular. To celebrate the 50th anniversary of the late William Friedkin's classic horror The Exorcist (1973) and the release of David Gordon Green's apprehensively anticipated rebootquel, The Exorcist: Believer (2023), we've scrabbled around in the oubliette and fished out not one but two Exorcist prequels: Renny Harlin's The Exorcist: The Beginning (2004) and Paul Schrader's Dominion: Prequel to the Excorcist (2005). That's two for the price of one! Well, more accurately, two for the price of two disastrous box office bombs based on the same premise with largely the same cast on the same sets but with different directors. It's quite simply the weirdest situation to ever befall a major horror franchise. How the hell did this happen? What are the differences? And crucially, are either of them worth exorcising and releasing into the world? Find out!
Did we set it free?
Make your call to reveal our verdict, our star rating out of five and our full review.
Skip the guess and read the review
EXORCIST: THE BEGINNING (2004), dir. Renny Harlin
VerdictRETURNED TO OBLIVION
Episode 137 put both Exorcist prequels side by side, with Cold Crash Pictures' Serge Bodnarchuk guiding us, and this is the one that reached cinemas first, though it was shot second.
Morgan Creek decided Paul Schrader's version wasn't scary, shelved it with a reported $30 million already spent, and hired Renny Harlin to remake it with the same star, much of the same Turkana supporting cast and the same cinematographer, Vittorio Storaro, this time almost entirely at Cinecittà. Stellan Skarsgård's Father Merrin, a lapsed priest haunted by a wartime atrocity, is now a bitter drunk in a fedora hired to excavate an impossibly old church in British-run East Africa, which made Conrad write 'Indiana Merrin' in his notes.
Harlin delivers what the studio wanted: a decapitated child in a dream within 20 minutes, CGI hyenas, maggots and crows, a callback Pazuzu statue, a woman investigating noises in a towel, jump scares every few seconds, and a twist that the possessed party is not the sickly boy but Izabella Scorupco's doctor, Sarah, which buys some Linda Blair makeup and no logical sense whatsoever. Two further twists change nothing. Merrin's war backstory arrives in showy flashbacks, Major Granville's moth-assisted suicide is unintentionally hilarious, and the climax has the demon playing chicken with Merrin in a tunnel before a green-screen stroll into Vatican City. Serge found it crass, making Africa the seat of evil while its people serve as cannon fodder, though one framing that echoes a Nazi execution lands. Dan, perversely, preferred it as a horror film, albeit the cheesiest he's ever seen.
Nobody actually recommended it, and back it goes.
DOMINION: PREQUEL TO THE EXORCIST (2005), dir. Paul Schrader
VerdictRETURNED TO OBLIVION
The second half of our Exorcist prequel double bill with Serge Bodnarchuk, and the first one shot.
After John Frankenheimer fell ill, Paul Schrader, writer of Taxi Driver, filmed the William Wisher and Caleb Carr script as written, partly on location in Morocco, and was fired when Morgan Creek decided it wasn't scary. His cut surfaced a year after Renny Harlin's remake, reportedly finished on $35,000 for post-production. Stellan Skarsgård's Merrin is already in East Africa, a priest on sabbatical rather than a drunk, and the wartime choice that broke his faith is told up front in one sober, classical prologue.
Gabriel Mann's idealistic Father Francis gets a real arc, Major Granville's despair builds to a sad, earned suicide, and the film sets the British Empire and the Catholic Church side by side as human evils, with Clara Bellar's Rachel observing that it's easier to believe evil is an ogre than a condition we all share. Serge called it philosophical horror, Schrader taking evil seriously. The trouble is the script's big idea: Satan cures the disabled boy Cheche (Filipino pop star Billy Crawford) and turns him into a glistening, androgynous figure in an unconvincing bald cap, lounging like Cleopatra in a way Conrad found camp and peculiarly sexy. Merrin pauses an exorcism for a costume change, the gore is tame, and it simply isn't frightening. Conrad thinks it's the more coherent character study; Dan found it slow and not really an Exorcist film.
Serge would free the pair as a lesson in studio meddling, but no patron voted to save this one on its own. Back in.
I kind of have to say that I enjoyed the Harlin movie more. Even though it was bad. It's still bad, but it kind of still works as a horror movie.
Dan All of it is just cranked up to 11 and it's a bit crass.
Conrad To Harlin, you know, evil is just jump scares.
Serge Bodnarchuk
Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.





