← The archive
Episode No.036

MirrorMask (2005)

Directed by Dave McKean. Starring Stephanie Leonidas, Jason Barry, Rob Brydon, Gina McKee.

Fantasy
MirrorMask

17 September 2019 · 1:04:25

The new Dark Crystal series on Netflix has given us an insatiable appetite for the fantasy worlds of Jim Henson, so we've plucked another of the company's films out of the oubliette. It's the tale of a young girl who argues with her parents and, after making a terrible wish about a family member that shockingly comes true, sets off on an adventure into a wild fantasy world to set the world to rights. No, it's not Labyrinth – it's MirrorMask (2005), written by none other than Neil Gaiman, featuring cutting-edge CGI and set in a post-apocalyptic hellscape: Brighton. What could go wrong? Quite a lot, actually.

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

A Jim Henson Company production written by Neil Gaiman and directed by illustrator Dave McKean, in which a circus teenager escapes into a dream-logic fantasy world after wishing her ailing mother away. On paper it's exactly our kind of thing: a dark, painterly companion piece to Labyrinth and The Dark Crystal, from people who've earned real goodwill in this genre. In practice, the film leans on early-2000s CGI that hasn't aged gracefully even by the standards of early-2000s CGI, and the story never quite escapes the shadow of the films it's clearly indebted to.

We split hard on this one. One of us found it derivative and visually inert, all artistic intent and no engagement: gorgeous individual images from McKean's own artwork, none of it adding up to a story worth following. The other saw a low-budget passion piece that overreached technically but still had something real underneath, worth a look for the ambition alone even while agreeing the CGI choice was a mistake. The coin of fate broke the tie in favour of freedom.

  • I got this horrible, naughty screensaver with a Kenny G soundtrack that made no sense whatsoever.
    Conrad
  • There's so much artistic intent, and it is just a passion piece. It was a low-budget, let's-see-if-we-can-make-this-film passion piece, and it just didn't quite succeed: a little too ambitious.
    Dan

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.