Melancholia (2011)
with Catherine Mary Stewart
Directed by Lars von Trier. Starring Kirsten Dunst, Charlotte Gainsbourg, Kiefer Sutherland, Alexander Skarsgård.

Catherine Mary Stewart brings Melancholia to the Oublietteers... that is, the Lars von Trier apocalyptic sci-fi drama, not a case of the blues. The gang have more fun talking about depression and the end of the world than one might reasonably expect, but does the film deserve to be set free or should it be set on a planetary collision course with oblivion?
Did we set it free?
Make your call to reveal our verdict, our star rating out of five and our full review.
Skip the guess and read the review
VerdictSet free
Our guest this episode was actress Catherine Mary Stewart, joining us for the show's first female-led discussion, on a film that splits neatly into two halves: a lavish, disastrous wedding reception where Kirsten Dunst's Justine slides deeper into depression in real time, and a slower second half where she and her sister wait out the arrival of a rogue planet on a collision course with Earth. Lars von Trier fuses arthouse character study with genuine end-of-the-world science fiction, and somehow neither half undercuts the other: the wedding is a Shakespearean-scale study of a woman coming apart, and the apocalypse plot gives that collapse a cosmic mirror, right down to the film's closing suggestion that Justine's clarity in the face of catastrophe was the sane response all along.
It's an unusual, demanding film that rewards more attention the more times you watch it, which all three of us had already done more than once before recording. The performances, score and visual design are all doing career-best work, and Von Trier's mix of the deeply personal and the genuinely cosmic gives it a rare kind of scale.
I love dramas that end in sad endings, for some reason. I like watching movies where marriages fall apart or families have feuds. There's something cathartic about it.
Dan It's a very romantic and beautiful exploration of depression. It's a fascinating character study of these two incredible women who may or may not be the same woman.
Conrad It's a fascinating film from a very unique genre, almost a genre of its own, by a very interesting writer and director who has always been very controversial. That's what makes it kind of fascinating.
Catherine Mary Stewart
Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.




