← The archive
Episode No.168

John Carter (2012)

Directed by Andrew Stanton. Starring Taylor Kitsch, Lynn Collins, Samantha Morton, Willem Dafoe.

Sci-fi
John Carter

24 February 2025 · 1:12:42

Still the biggest box office bomb of all time, adjusted for inflation, John Carter (2012) was a brave attempt to give Edgar Rice Burroughs' influential sci-fi novel 'A Princess of Mars' the summer blockbuster treatment... 40 years after George Lucas and everyone else had pretty much raided all of its ideas for space opera hits. But is the film really that bad? Does it share the 'Mars movie' curse? Or did it just get lost in the shuffle in 2012 because of poor marketing? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

Just the two of us this time, and one of the most notorious flops in Hollywood history, released on 9 March 2012 to mark a century since Edgar Rice Burroughs serialised A Princess of Mars.

Taylor Kitsch plays the Confederate veteran who ducks into an Arizona cave and wakes on Mars, where the lower gravity lets him leap like a proto-Superman. He's captured by the four-armed Tharks, led by Willem Dafoe's Tars Tarkas, and drawn into a war between Helium and Zodanga, whose ruler, Dominic West's Sab Than, is backed by Mark Strong's shape-shifting Therns. Lynn Collins plays the scientist-princess Dejah Thoris, whose British accent was convincing enough to fool her co-stars.

The road to the screen took eight decades, from Bob Clampett's 1930s animation tests through John McTiernan, Robert Rodriguez and Jon Favreau, before Stanton made his live-action debut. The title lost "of Mars" along the way, and the film took $284 million worldwide on a net budget of about $264 million, opening second to The Lorax. The planned sequels went down with it.

Dan calls it the godfather of the genre. He loves the world-building, and Woola, the lizard-dog who proves that any creature becomes lovable once you give it the habits of a dog. Conrad finds the leads wooden, with Kitsch a charisma vacuum who has no arc, and the names and factions an alienating blur. Matters aren't helped by a hero who sounds like his plumber. He doesn't think it deserved the pasting, but it still doesn't work for him.

Dan set it free, Conrad threw it back, and 70 per cent of the patrons tipped the scales Dan's way.

  • I think it's unfortunate that it was criticized when it came out. I think it's a great movie, despite the wooden acting.
    Dan
  • I don't think it deserved the pasting that it got, but I still don't think it works.
    Conrad

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.