A Little Princess (1995)
Directed by Alfonso Cuaron. Starring Liesel Matthews, Eleanor Bron, Liam Cunningham, Rusty Schwimmer.

Thanks to a nomination from our patron, Eddie, we're getting locked in the attic with Alfonso Cuarón's Frances Hodgson Burnett adaptation A Little Princess (1995) – his first English-language film, made with an unknown child lead, a script by The Fisher King's Richard LaGravenese, and a cinematographer, Emmanuel Lubezki, who'd go on to shoot most of Cuarón's career alongside him. The result, the third screen version of Burnett's 1905 novel after outings for Mary Pickford and Shirley Temple, follows Sara Crewe, a wealthy, warmly imaginative girl deposited at a New York boarding school while her father serves in the First World War — and what happens to both her fortunes and her sense of self once the money, and the news from the front, turn bad. It bombed at the box office on release in May 1995, picked up two Oscar nominations anyway, and quietly became the film Cuarón has called his personal favourite of everything he's directed. But does it deserve to let out of the Oubliette? Find out!
Did we set it free?
Make your call to reveal our verdict, our star rating out of five and our full review.
Skip the guess and read the review
VerdictSet free
Eddie Whittingham's pick from the Oubliette roulette, and new to both of us. At 12, Dan thought the title wasn't for him, and at 20, Conrad thought the same.
It's 1914, and Sara Crewe (Liesel Matthews) is sent from India to a New York boarding school while her father (Liam Cunningham) goes to war. When he's reported dead and his money disappears, headmistress Miss Minchin (Eleanor Bron) puts Sara to work in the attic alongside Becky, the school's servant. Sara survives on her belief that every girl is a princess and on the stories she tells about the Ramayana.
Cuarón's English-language debut, and reportedly his own favourite of his films, is a showcase for what he'd go on to do on Prisoner of Azkaban. Emmanuel Lubezki's camera sits at a child's eye level, Bo Welch's sets loom, and the whole school is coded in green, with Sara's kindness and her eventual happiness in gold. The two Oscar nominations were deserved. It's dark for a family film, with war, poverty and open racism, and its magical-realist touches play up the novel's colonial "magical native" in Ram Dass instead of questioning it. Matthews holds her own without quite carrying the emotion, but the supporting cast is a treat. Patrick Doyle's score, with an 11-year-old Abigail Doyle singing "Kindle My Heart", was more inventive than Conrad expected. The snowy attic dance was reportedly invented on the day, when a planned effects sequence was cut. The storybook CGI is the weak spot.
We both set it free, and so did the patrons. It flopped in 1995, so it's long overdue a rediscovery.
I think it is overlooked in Cuarón's filmography. And I think people should check it out if they haven't seen it.
Conrad It's an impeccably made movie.
Dan
Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.


