The Vanishing (1993)
with Travis Milloy
Directed by George Sluizer. Starring Jeff BridgesRegular, Kiefer Sutherland, Nancy Travis, Sandra Bullock.

Dan and Conrad dig up The Vanishing (1993), the scorned Hollywood remake of a dark psychological thriller, and re-appraise it with writer/director Travis Milloy.
Did we set it free?
Make your call to reveal our verdict, our star rating out of five and our full review.
Skip the guess and read the review
VerdictSet free
An unusual case: George Sluizer remaking his own 1988 Dutch thriller Spoorloos for Hollywood, five years on, with Jeff Bridges as the outwardly ordinary chemistry teacher who's spent years perfecting the abduction of a stranger, and Kiefer Sutherland as the boyfriend who spends three obsessive years hunting for the girlfriend (Sandra Bullock, in her first screen role) who vanished at a rest stop. Sluizer keeps the original's structure and most of its best ideas, including telling the abductor's method from his own clinical point of view well before the crime happens, but swaps the source film's famously bleak, inevitable ending for something closer to a rescue thriller.
Our guest this episode, screenwriter Travis Milloy (Pandorum), came to this one having loved the original first and never recovered from the substitution, and made no secret of it. We landed differently: this earns real respect as a piece of Hollywood genre filmmaking in its own right, retains a vulnerable male lead and empowered female lead that 90s psycho-thrillers rarely bothered with, and stands up to rewatching in a way its contemporaries like Single White Female largely don't. We voted two to one to set it free, with the strong recommendation that you watch Spoorloos as well.
I really enjoyed it. I found the start of it kind of hard to get into, but once the plot started rolling along, I was really invested.
Dan I think it deserves to get a little bit more respect than it does. It talks about obsession in interesting ways, and I'd vote to set it free on the proviso that you watch the original as well.
Conrad I strongly believe it should be buried, more than six feet deep. I'm coming from a very jaded perspective, because the original so powerfully affected me. I respect the things about it that are good, but this movie should never have existed.
Travis Milloy
Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.




