← The archive
Episode No.128

The Puppet Masters (1994)

with Joe Lipsett

Directed by Stuart Orme. Starring Donald Sutherland, Eric Thal, Julie Warner, Keith David.

HorrorSci-fiGuest: Joe Lipsett (Critics & Creators)
The Puppet Masters (with Joe Lipsett)

12 June 2023 · 1:12:59

Film critic and Horror Queers co-host Joe Lipsett joins us to explore the body snatching invasion thriller The Puppet Masters (1994), an adaptation of Robert A. Heinlein's 1951 sci-fi novel starring Donald Sutherland, Eric Thal, Julie Warner, Keith David, Will Patton and Yaphet Kotto. Astonishing practical effects abound as parasitic manta rays from space leap merrily onto the backs of unsuspecting cast members, turning them into mindless drones bent on world domination. Their only giveaway? They have no interest whatsoever in Julie Warner's cleavage. Seriously, this is a plot point. It's gleeful straight-to-video fun from the height of the X-Files era, but does it hold up? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

Horror Queers' Joe Lipsett rented this from his local video shop a couple of times a year as a teenager, for reasons that became clear once we reached the shower scene.

Robert A. Heinlein's 1951 novel predates Invasion of the Body Snatchers, but by 1994 the film inevitably played as a copy, with Donald Sutherland in both. Sutherland's spymaster Andrew Nivens, his son Sam (Eric Thal) and exobiologist Mary (Julie Warner) investigate a supposed UFO landing in a small Midwestern town and find its people ridden by stingray-shaped parasites from Titan, plugged into their spines and a hive mind. It's very X-Files, right down to the woman in the pantsuit. Mary spots the infected by noticing which men aren't staring at her chest, which says plenty.

After reported passes from Ted Elliott and Terry Rossio and from David S. Goyer, the plot lurches from small-town mystery to a body-hopping conspiracy around a never-named president and back again, like three episodes glued together. The heroes cheerfully gun down civilians, Richard Belzer's withdrawal subplot goes nowhere, and Sam starts out a sexist bore. But the slimy silicone creatures from Greg Cannom's team, swinging from ceiling fans and hanging in clusters off a man's torso, are superb practical effects. A few scenes are properly creepy, notably a mother surrounded by silent neighbours, while a possessed chimp typing 'DO YOU MISS ME, SAM?' had Conrad in hysterics. It opened fourth in October 1994 and reportedly made about $8 million. Joe loves it, Dan enjoyed it and Conrad found it a well-made mixed bag.

The patrons voted roughly 60–40 to set it free.

  • It feels like a lost episode or extended episode of the X-Files, but I did really appreciate the effects.
    Dan
  • It is a straight-to-video rental, but it's one of those ones that you keep finding yourself wanting to watch occasionally.
    Conrad
  • I think when the movie is working, it's really, really working.
    Joe Lipsett

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.