← The archive
Episode No.071

A Perfect Murder (1998)

with Joe Lipsett

Directed by Andrew Davis. Starring Michael Douglas, Gwyneth Paltrow, Viggo Mortensen, David Suchet.

HorrorGuest: Joe Lipsett (Critics & Creators)
A Perfect Murder (with Joe Lipsett)

22 February 2021 · 1:03:47

Bloody Disgusting's Joe Lispett joins us to share his love of 90s erotic thrillers and revisit one of the most-overlooked entries in the genre: A Perfect Murder (1998), Andrew Davis's remake of Hitchcock's Dial 'M' for Murder starring the obligatory Michael Douglas, the permanently gaslit Gwyneth Paltrow and steamy pre-Aragorn Viggo Mortensen. It's a twisty turny tale of sex, inheritances, Chernobyl-level stock market meltdowns and murder with a meat thermometer – but does it deserve to get away from the oubliette scot-free or should it be permanently lost along with Gwyneth's apartment key?

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictThrown back

Joe Lipsett, one half of the Horror Queers, returned without his co-host to make the case for the erotic thriller, a genre he loves and one that's now all but extinct. Andrew Davis's 1998 remake of Hitchcock's Dial M for Murder makes Michael Douglas a Wall Street player on the slide who discovers that his heiress wife Emily (Gwyneth Paltrow) is sleeping with an artist (Viggo Mortensen), and blackmails the lover into killing her so that he can inherit her fortune.

The first half is terrific: sumptuous apartments shot by Dariusz Wolski, Douglas at full throttle, Mortensen mumbling seductively among paintings he did himself, and an exceptionally well-staged murder attempt. Then it falls apart. Paltrow never shares another scene with Mortensen, the triangle that should drive the story collapses, the film loses interest in being erotic, and the climax hinges on a gun that seems to come from nowhere. David Suchet's detective steals the film in two short scenes and is wasted. Dan prefers the original, corny as it is, and none of us knew who we were meant to be rooting for.

Unanimous: back into the oubliette it goes, cleft chins and all.

  • He walks in with the bag of brand-new shoes and she says nothing at all. It just made me think, wow, they must be so rich. They buy shoes every single day. No one asks any questions. It's just, whatever, shoes.
    Dan
  • He's basically the same character he was in Wall Street, but murdering his wife.
    Conrad
  • If we could have had an entire film from the first half, this movie would be a slam dunk. But it just falls apart so badly in the back half. It's so boring. And that's a cardinal sin that I can't forgive an erotic thriller for: it should never be boring.
    Joe Lipsett

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.