The Shadow (1994)
with Oliver Harper
Directed by Russell Mulcahy. Starring Alec Baldwin, John Lone, Penelope Ann Miller, Peter Boyle.

Retrospective reviewer extraordinaire, documentary filmmaker and action movie editor Oliver Harper joins us to probe the dark recesses of The Shadow (1994) – Russell Mulcahy's would-be summer blockbuster superhero adventure starring Alec Baldwin, Penelope Ann Miller, Jone Lone, Peter Boyle, Tim Curry and Ian McKellan (pre-Sir!). It has an action packed soundtrack from Jerry Goldsmith, a hero with mind control abilities locked in mortal combat with the last descendent of Genghis Khan, and a Taylor Dayne end title power ballad. What more could you want?! Well, moviegoers in 1994 who were hooked on Speed wanted a lot more, and stayed away in droves. But were they wrong? Who knows? The Shadow knows!
Did we set it free?
Make your call to reveal our verdict, our star rating out of five and our full review.
Skip the guess and read the review
VerdictSet free
Oliver Harper, YouTube retrospective reviewer and director of the definitive Street Fighter II documentary, joined us for Universal's bid to turn a 1930s radio narrator into the next Batman. He first caught it on VHS in 1995; for us it was a first watch.
Alec Baldwin is Lamont Cranston, a Tibetan opium warlord reformed by a holy man and taught to cloud men's minds, who returns to New York as a cackling vigilante with a network of ring-wearing agents linked by pneumatic tubes worthy of Brazil. His nemesis is John Lone's Shiwan Khan, last descendant of Genghis Khan, who wants an atomic bomb that hasn't been invented yet. Dan kept seeing a Batman copy, though the Shadow came first.
David Koepp's script gives the hero a dark past so he knows evil first-hand, then does little with it. Nobody can say what the powers allow (how do you hide an entire hotel from a city?), the action is sparse, and the hall-of-mirrors finale feels truncated, after an earthquake destroyed the set. The tone lurches: a hypnotised sailor begs to be stopped as he leaps from the Empire State Building, then his descent is played for laughs.
What survives is the look. Stephen H. Burum's lighting shifts on set whenever Baldwin hypnotises someone, the miniatures of a Gothic New York are gorgeous, and Jerry Goldsmith's score weaves the Shadow's swooshes into the music. Baldwin and Penelope Ann Miller spark nicely, Lone is a terrific villain and Ian McKellen is wasted as a colourblind boffin.
Oliver and Dan set it free, Conrad sat on the fence, and the patrons voted 83 to 17 to let it out.
It's not a perfect movie, it's not a bad movie, it's just a very easy film to watch.
Oliver Harper It's kind of all the things I wish comic book movies were still, because they're just so serious now.
Dan It's beautiful to look at. It doesn't make a lot of sense. Tonally, it's a bit all over the map.
Conrad
Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.




