← The archive
Episode No.177

Superman Returns (2006)

with Oliver Harper

Directed by Bryan Singer. Starring Brandon Routh, Kate Bosworth, Kevin Spacey, James Marsden.

Sci-fiFantasyGuest: Oliver Harper (Critics & Creators)
Superman Returns (with Oliver Harper)

1 July 2025 · 1:11:56

Oliver Harper joins us to celebrate James Gunn's reboot of the Superman franchise by looking back at Bryan Singer's Superman Returns (2006), which tends to get lost in the mix when discussing previous attempts to revive the DC superhero. It boldly attempted to pick up the thread of the Christopher Reeve/Richard Donner era Superman and act as a sequel to Superman II (1980), with the charming (then unknown) Brandon Routh channeling Reeve in his portrayal of the man of steel and his bumbling alter ego. Despite its stellar casting, John Williams musical themes, and lavish production values, it failed to soar at the box office, leading to the cancellation of its sequel and a rethink that led us to Zack Snyder's series 7 years later. But is it a nostalgia pandering misfire or a misunderstood gem that deserves to return? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictThrown back

With yet another Superman reboot heading for cinemas, returning guest Oliver Harper joined us to revisit the last one. Oliver was a projectionist at Cineworld Cambridge in 2006 and saw it at a preview, having followed every leak on the fan forums; Dan, by his own admission the least Superman-minded person alive, came to it cold.

Singer pitched a sequel to the first two Christopher Reeve films that ignored III and IV. Superman (Brandon Routh, 26, the same age Reeve was) returns from five years searching for the remains of Krypton to find that Lois Lane (Kate Bosworth) has won a Pulitzer for an article titled Why the World Doesn't Need Superman, is engaged to James Marsden's Richard and has a five-year-old son. Meanwhile Kevin Spacey's Lex Luthor, fresh out of prison, plans to grow a new continent from crystals stolen from the Fortress of Solitude.

The two plots barely touch until the last act. Superman's first line concerns a crystal he's buried in the garden, then he spends half an hour being reproached for leaving. The shuttle and 777 rescue is terrific, and Singer could have opened with it; the bullet bouncing off an eyeball still makes audiences flinch. John Ottman's reworking of the Williams themes mostly works, though the romantic flight is murky and clumsily scored. Oliver loathes the suit, the teal grade and the decision to shoot on early digital cameras, and thinks Parker Posey's Kitty would have made a better Lois. Spacey, at least, is having a ball. Noel Neill, TV's original Lois, plays the dying heiress Lex swindles in the opening scene. It took nearly $400 million worldwide, which wasn't enough to secure the planned sequel.

Oliver couldn't decide. Neither of us could recommend it, and the patrons threw it back overwhelmingly, patron Iconographer's tearful defence notwithstanding.

  • It just didn't have any sense of drive towards anything. It just had a big middle section that was just not really going in any direction.
    Dan
  • It's overlong. There's not enough action in it. The characterisations don't work particularly well. And I just wasn't invested in it, particularly apart from the plane rescue.
    Conrad
  • There's loads of, like, potential there. It just needed something more. I think the script needed more work.
    Oliver Harper

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.