← The archive
Episode No.106

City of Ember (2008)

Directed by Gil Kenan. Starring Saoirse Ronan, Harry Treadaway, Bill Murray, Tim RobbinsRegular.

Sci-fiFantasy
City of Ember

11 July 2022 · 1:10:09

Dan and Conrad slip into some chunky knit sweaters and go underground to explore City of Ember (2008), a post-apocalyptic science fantasy starring Harry Treadaway, Saoirse Ronan, Bill Murray and Tim Robbins. Based on a popular series of novels by Jeanne DuPrau, which became the focus of an intense bidding war when it came time for the film adaptation, the film seems to presage the explosion of young adult dystopian adventures that would follow in the wake of The Hunger Games in the 2010s. But should the film be rekindled, or should the ember be extinguished in the oubliette forever? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictThrown back

Two hundred years after its builders sealed humanity underground to survive a ruined surface, the city of Ember is falling apart.

The generator is failing, the lights keep cutting out, and the box of instructions for getting out has long been forgotten. Messenger Lina Mayfleet (Saoirse Ronan) and pipeworks boy Doon Harrow (Harry Treadaway) find it, half eaten by Lina's baby sister, and follow it to the letter. Monster House director Gil Kenan and Edward Scissorhands writer Caroline Thompson adapt Jeanne DuPrau's novel on a $55 million budget, with Tom Hanks's company producing and a vast set built in the old Harland and Wolff paint hall in Belfast.

It looks wonderful: steampunk by way of Wallace and Gromit, all knitwear and extension cables, like a Laika stop-motion film in live action. But nobody has an arc, the puzzles solve themselves, and every setup, from Lina's love of speed to Doon's mechanical knack, goes nowhere. Bill Murray's mayor in a fat suit is no threat, Tim Robbins and Martin Landau are wasted, and key moments, Granny's death included, are staged so vaguely we couldn't tell what had happened. Giant mutant animals turn up and nobody seems surprised, though the star-nosed mole is the best effect in it. Andrew Lockington's busy, pleasant score sounds suspiciously like Narnia. It made under $18 million and the planned sequels died with it. Dan thinks it works for small children; Conrad thinks kids deserve better, and talked Dan round.

Back it goes.

  • Like, if you had no sound and you're not following the story, it looks like a really good movie.
    Dan
  • It's the story of two kids in an isolated society who find some IKEA instructions and their only challenge is the fact that the sister ate part of them. That's it. That's your movie.
    Conrad

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.