← The archive
Episode No.142

The Postman (1997)

with Mikey Neumann and Zoe Wells

Directed by Kevin Costner. Starring Kevin Costner, Will PattonRegular, Larenz Tate, Olivia Williams.

Sci-fiGuest: Zoe Wells and Mikey Neumann (Critics & Creators)
The Postman (with Mikey Neumann and Zoe Wells)

29 January 2024 · 1:16:18

We're back at last! And what better way to start the year than being reunited with FilmJoy's Mikey Neumann and Zoe Wells for another Kevin Costner apocalypse movie? This time it's 1997's The Postman – the tale of a travelling one-man-and-one-mule Shakespeare company who, after his acting partner is killed and turned into paste by a roving fascist militia, accidentally starts a religion around a basic infrastructure service that brings hope to the ragged survivors of the third world war. It's heartfelt. It's three hours long. It strangely features most of Kevin's children – in one case, as a townsperson who makes a pass at him. But is it a bloated vanity project or a hidden gem that's more relevant now than it was in the 90s? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictThrown back

Zoe Wells and Mikey Neumann of the YouTube channel Film Joy helped us defend Waterworld a while back and promised to return for another Kevin Costner apocalypse. They kept their word, all 177 minutes of it.

In the war- and plague-ravaged America of 2013, Costner is a drifting Shakespeare-reciting loner whose mule, Bill, is the best thing in the film. Press-ganged by Will Patton's General Bethlehem, a photocopier salesman turned warlord whose white-nationalist militia unwinds by watching The Sound of Music, he escapes, takes a dead mail carrier's uniform, and bluffs his way into food by claiming the Restored United States has reopened the post. The lie becomes a movement, a postal army and finally a statue of himself.

Dan thinks there's a solid two-hour film in here somewhere. What we got instead is the Waterworld template again (a loner with a sweet ride, a villain, a town that wants his good genes) and a climactic duel that pleads for wars to be fought only by the men who start them, then becomes five minutes of slow-motion rolling in the dirt. Abby (Olivia Williams) is a crack shot reduced to the vessel of Costner's child, three of his real children turn up in the cast, and Tom Petty appears as himself, giving no discernible hoots.

James Newton Howard's score is rousing, if alarmingly close to Apollo 13, and the scenery, costumes and Bill's star turn in a Shakespearean sword fight are a pleasure. It went on to win all five Razzies it was nominated for.

Dan and two-thirds of the patrons wanted it set free. Conrad, Zoe and Mikey outvoted them, three to two, so it's return to sender.

  • I think Kevin Costner should be the one to shoot this movie in the back. You did this.
    Mikey Neumann
  • I think it should stay in the Oubliette, except for like GIFs from like certain scenes.
    Zoe Wells
  • I think if you trimmed like an hour of this movie, it would be a pretty solid, not a great film, but pretty solid.
    Dan

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.