← The archive
Episode No.179

Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer (2007)

with Zoe Wells and Mikey Neumann

Directed by Tim Story. Starring Ioan Gruffudd, Jessica Alba, Chris EvansRegular, Michael Chiklis.

Sci-fiFantasyGuest: Zoe Wells and Mikey Neumann (Critics & Creators)
Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer (with Zoe Wells and Mikey Neumann)

29 July 2025 · 1:16:55

Zoe Wells and Mikey Neumann of FilmJoy join us to revisit Tim Story's superhero sequel Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer (2007). Released 2 years after Fox's surprising box office success with the original, the film marks a transitional moment in superhero cinema. Neither beloved or entirely dismissed, it's a sequel that manages to improve on its predecessor with world-ending stakes while still feeling oddly weightless and safe. Arriving just before the Marvel juggernaut truly found its stride with the release of Iron Man the following year, it flirted with cosmic grandeur (reimagining Galactus as an ominous V'ger style space cloud) while keeping one foot firmly planted in the PG, family-friendly camp with its will-they-won't-they wedding B-plot. As a second attempt at a reboot tops the box office, is it worth revisiting this one and enjoying its strengths? Or is it rightly consigned to oblivion? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictThrown back

With another Fantastic Four on its way, Film Joy's Mikey Neumann and Zoe Wells, our fellow Kevin Costner survivors, joined us for the 2007 sequel. None of us remembered a thing about it.

Reed (Ioan Gruffudd) and Sue (Jessica Alba) are trying to get married at the Baxter Building when the Silver Surfer (Doug Jones, voiced by Laurence Fishburne) crashes the ceremony, heralding Galactus, devourer of worlds, who has a taste for Earth. Julian McMahon's Doctor Doom returns to help, then betrays them.

At a brisk 91 minutes, it sits at the hinge between Sam Raimi's Spider-Man and the MCU, which Iron Man launched a year later. The effects mostly hold up. Galactus is rendered as a cosmic cloud, which upset comic fans but looks spectacular swallowing the rings of Saturn, and the Surfer, phasing through buildings, is the best thing in it. Michael Chiklis's foam-suited Thing gets the warmest performance and the least to do. The London Eye rescue is the film's high point, achieved without anyone from the cast or crew setting foot in London. Then a power-swapping gimmick goes nowhere, Sue dies and is revived within a minute, and the film treats her as an object, from the wigs and blue contacts to yet another gag about her being naked in public. Zoe paused it three times in the first 20 minutes. Chris Evans's Johnny Storm is a cheerful cad, and John Ottman's theme sounded to Conrad like Roll Out the Barrel. Stan Lee's cameo, being turned away from the wedding, nods, according to Story, to the comic, where Lee and Jack Kirby were refused entry too.

Dan, enjoying it as a guilty pleasure, would recommend it. Mikey, Zoe and Conrad wouldn't, and 83 per cent of the patrons fed it to the cloud.

  • I think maybe it's a guilty pleasure for me. Maybe I'm just thinking, oh, this is just one of those movies that I know is bad, but I still enjoy.
    Dan
  • But still, ultimately, I do realise why I completely forgot about it. It just doesn't do much.
    Conrad
  • The new movie does all of this better. I can say that without thinking about it.
    Mikey Neumann

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.