← The archive
Episode No.152

The Black Hole (1979)

Directed by Gary Nelson. Starring Maximilian Schell, Anthony PerkinsRegular, Robert Forster, Joseph Bottoms.

Sci-fi
The Black Hole

17 June 2024 · 1:12:53

Dan and Conrad venture into Disney's 'dark era' again – this time with a sci-fi twist! It's The Black Hole (1979), the mouse house's answer to the colossal box-office and cultural phenomenon of Star Wars two years prior. And like all dark era flops, it uncomfortably straddles mature themes (an egomaniacal scientist determined to journey through a massive black hole and willing to enslave his entire crew as zombified androids to do his bidding) with family-friendly fun (robots with Disney eyes having laser battles). The result is a grandiose, steampunk adventure with stilted dialogue, eye-popping visuals and a doom-laden score by John Barry at his finest... but is it any good? Or are Conrad's nostalgia goggles deceiving him? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

Our patrons voted this to the top of their pooled nominations, ahead of The Frighteners. It's a childhood favourite of Conrad's, watched mostly pan-and-scanned on British TV, so badly that one robot's death scene was just a wobbling wall. Dan was sure he'd seen it and remembered none of it.

The crew of the USS Palomino, led by Robert Forster's stoic captain, find the long-lost Cygnus parked at the edge of a black hole. Aboard are Maximilian Schell's Dr Hans Reinhardt, an army of robots and Maximilian, a floating red-eyed henchman with blender attachments. Anthony Perkins plays the starstruck scientist, and their own robot Vincent (an uncredited Roddy McDowall) looks suspiciously like a Henry hoover.

Disney conceived it as a disaster movie in space, then Star Wars arrived and the robots got lasers. It falls between those stools: doom-laden hard SF about a megalomaniac on the brink, alongside sentry robots that topple off gantries like shop dummies. When it turns dark, though, it doesn't flinch. The masked drones turn out to be the lobotomised crew, and Maximilian's killing of Perkins, who holds up a book that is shredded as he dies, still horrifies. Schell's improvised "Protect me from Maximilian" is a gift.

The matte paintings and in-house motion-control effects remain gorgeous, especially a molten meteor rolling down a corridor at the cast. John Barry's swirling score, the first ever recorded digitally, earns its place, bar one trumpety battle anthem. The ending, a literal trip through heaven and hell, makes no sense.

Conrad adores it with nostalgia goggles firmly on; Dan found it dated but had a fantastic time. The patrons voted 92 to 8.

  • It was much, much more complex in terms of themes and concepts than I would ever have envisioned from Disney in the 70s.
    Dan
  • I still absolutely adore this movie. I know the dialogue is atrocious in a lot of places.
    Conrad

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.