← The archive
Episode No.082

Silent Running (1972)

Directed by Douglas Trumbull. Starring Bruce Dern, Cliff Potts, Ron Rifkin, Jesse Vint.

Sci-fi
Silent Running

26 July 2021 · 59:57

Space botanist Bruce Dern murders his crewmates and hijacks his spaceship on a joyride through Saturns rings after he finds out his gardens are scheduled for destruction in Silent Running (1972), an eco-sci-fi film directed by special effects mastermind Douglas Trumbull. But will Dan and Conrad slip into a comfortable bathrobe and enjoy digging into this 70s cult classic, or will Joan Baez's vibrato drive them into a Dern-style, wide-eyed mania? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

Patron Matt Fisher pointed us at Douglas Trumbull's directing debut, and we came back with mixed feelings and sore ears.

Bruce Dern is Freeman Lowell, botanist aboard the Valley Forge, one of a fleet of freighters orbiting Saturn with Earth's last forests in geodesic domes. When the order comes to nuke them, he kills his crewmates and runs off with a dome and three drones he christens Huey, Dewey and Louie. The craft is undeniable: a decommissioned aircraft carrier doubles as the ship, front projection stands in for optical compositing, and the drones are performers who were double amputees walking on their hands.

You can see the lived-in industrial sci-fi of Outland and Alien being born here, along with R2-D2's ancestors. The premise, though, is Joni Mitchell ecology, there's gravity everywhere, and our botanist can't work out why his plants are dying in the dark. We're meant to sympathise with Lowell; half a century on he looks like a wide-eyed psychopath who also runs over a robot. Then Joan Baez warbles over the bunny montages, three times. The final shot of a lone drone tending the garden as it drifts into space is still haunting.

Conrad would throw it back; Dan would release it with warnings. The coin of fate came up tails for Dan, so off it drifts.

  • So despite my actual dislike to watching this movie, I think it's important that people should watch it... So I would actually release this with warnings.
    Dan
  • He just looks like a psychopath to me who murders people for no reason and worst of all runs over a robot, which was the only cute thing left in the movie.
    Conrad

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.