The Adventures of Pluto Nash (2003)
Directed by Ron Underwood. Starring Eddie Murphy, Randy QuaidRegular, Rosario Dawson, Joe Pantoliano.

One of our Patreons nominated Eddie Murphy's notorious 2003 sci-fi action 'comedy' The Adventures of Pluto Nash for this episode, which on paper should have been promising. Its star was coming off a string of family-friendly comedies like The Nutty Professor, Dr. Dolittle and Shrek. Its supporting cast includes Randy Quaid, Rosario Dawson, Joe Pantoliano, Jay Mohr, Pam Grier and John Cleese. It's directed by quirky action/comedy wunderkind Ron Underwood of Tremors fame and has a budget north of $100 million. What could possibly go wrong?! A lot, it turns out. Quite a lot. But despite being the biggest box office flop of all time when it was released, it hasn't emerged as either a reclaimed cult classic or a so-bad-it's-good guilty pleasure... it's been largely forgotten. So, let's take a look at this curio and decide whether we're over the moon with it... or hitting the abort button before it causes collateral damage!
Did we set it free?
Make your call to reveal our verdict, our star rating out of five and our full review.
Skip the guess and read the review
VerdictThrown back
Patron Scooper Pete nominated this alongside Battlefield Earth, probably as a joke, and the wheel picked it.
It's 2080, and Eddie Murphy's Pluto Nash runs the best nightclub on the moon until a shadowy mobster called Rex Crater blows it up for refusing to sell. Pluto goes on the run with Rosario Dawson's singer Dina and Randy Quaid's obsolete bodyguard android Bruno, who never blinks, steams while recharging and steals every scene he's in. Murphy reportedly asked for the script to be played straight on the promise that he'd bring the comedy himself. According to editor Paul Hirsch's memoir, he didn't, and he turned down Ron Underwood's suggestions on the grounds that he'd done that sort of thing before.
Hirsch was fired after an unauthorised preview test, the opening and ending were rewritten and reshot once Murphy was free again six months later, and the film reportedly took $7.1 million worldwide on a $100 million budget. Murphy is a charisma vacuum, Dawson is reduced to asking whether he's going to leave her, and the camera ogles a sexy maid robot in close-up. The big twist is that the villain is Pluto's own clone, with no reason given for why he turned out evil. The tacky commercialised future has its moments, and the hover cars and extensive miniature work are good, but the sets have a whiff of theme park, and John Powell's scratch-and-brass score sank Conrad's spirits from the rap 'Blue Moon' onwards. John Cleese's indignant car AI raised a smile. Dan quite enjoyed it the first time; a second viewing finished it off.
Thrown back, unanimously, patrons included.
Watching this movie a second time, oof, not good. Really not good.
Dan Just $100 million worth of craftsmanship and skill put into creating a completely dead-on-arrival movie that has very little to recommend it and very little entertainment value.
Conrad
Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.


