← The archive
Episode No.094

The Mothman Prophecies (2002)

featuring Mark Pellington

Directed by Mark Pellington. Starring Richard Gere, Laura Linney, Will PattonRegular, Debra Messing.

HorrorSci-fiGuest: Mark Pellington (Filmmakers)
The Mothman Prophecies (featuring Mark Pellington)

24 January 2022 · 1:13:25

Director Mark Pellington joins us to mark the 20th anniversary of the release of The Mothman Prophecies, a quietly disturbing supernatural thriller starring Richard Gere as a grief-stricken journalist who finds himself in a small West Virginia town helping a local police officer, Laura Linney, investigate a series of escalating unexplainable events. Based on a true account of a tragic disaster in Point Pleasant, the film's unique visual and audio style was hugely influential, but how does it hold up 20 years later? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

For its 20th anniversary, director Mark Pellington joined us and revealed that the voice of Indrid Cold, the film's deeply unsettling phone presence, is his own, doubled, tripled and stretched by sound designer Claude Letessier.

Richard Gere is John Klein, a Washington reporter whose wife (Debra Messing) dies after seeing something on the road, and who finds himself inexplicably in a West Virginia town where people keep seeing a winged figure and taking calls that predict disaster. Pellington fought to show as little of the Mothman as possible, and the film is all the better for it: a story of grief and powerlessness told through sound and image rather than plot.

Gere gives possibly his best performance, quietly coming apart, and Laura Linney's pragmatic police officer Connie is a joy, open-minded but unflappable. Will Patton's haunted Gordon is heartbreaking. Pellington hired his sound designer before his cinematographer, and tomandandy's score of scraped guitars and Tibetan bowls seeds the bridge collapse from the very first scene. Even its happy accidents, from light-streaked footage to a startled extra in a car, became part of its texture. Watch it on headphones. Twenty years on, it has aged beautifully. Set free with enthusiasm.

  • Ideal situation to watch this either on headphones or with a really good sound system because, yeah, sonically, it is something that is more felt than seen almost.
    Dan
  • But I do actually think this is his best performance.
    Conrad
  • In Mothman Prophecies, we hired our sound designer before we hired our cinematographer.
    Mark Pellington

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.