Solaris (2002)
with Alex Heeney
Directed by Steven Soderbergh. Starring George Clooney, Natascha McElhone, Jeremy Davies, Viola Davis.

Alex Heeney, Editor-in-Chief at The Seventh Row, joins us to explore a simulacra of Solaris – Steven Soderberg's remake of the Tarkovsky classic. Produced by James Cameron and led by George Clooney, the result is a lean, melancholic adaptation of Stanisław Lem’s most famous novel. It follows psychologist Chris Kelvin (Clooney) to a failing space station orbiting the enigmatic planet Solaris, where memory, guilt, and desire take physical form in ways that are equal parts sci-fi premise and emotional trap. It's a studio movie with art-film discipline, a romance wrapped inside an existential problem, and an example of the marketing department losing a fight it never fully understood. It underperformed badly at the box office and has largely served as a footnote to discussions of the Tarkovsky original, in the "oh yeah, that happened" vein, but does it deserve to be reassessed on its own merits? Find out!
Alex prepared a special treat for listeners over on Seventh Row: a suggestion for an ideal sci-fi comedy film to watch next after Solaris in which the genders of the main characters are swapped. What to find out more? Head on over to http://seventh-row.com/oubliette to find out more!
Did we set it free?
Make your call to reveal our verdict, our star rating out of five and our full review.
Skip the guess and read the review
VerdictSet free
Alex Heeney, founder of Seventh Row, joined us. All three of us first saw it years ago, and none of us had seen Tarkovsky's version first. Dan has since caught up with it.
Psychologist Chris Kelvin (George Clooney) is sent to a space station orbiting the planet Solaris, where the crew have stopped communicating. He finds two bodies, two cryptic survivors (Viola Davis and Jeremy Davies) and a small boy who shouldn't be there. Then his dead wife, Rheya (Natascha McElhone), appears in his quarters, rebuilt from his memories.
Produced by James Cameron and written and directed by Soderbergh, it trades Stanisław Lem's novel about the impossibility of understanding an alien mind for a chamber piece about grief, guilt and whether we ever really know the people we love. At 99 minutes it reaches space in eight, where Tarkovsky took 43. The station is cold blue and silver, and the Earth flashbacks are warm amber, with McElhone's Rheya admitting she's only what Kelvin remembers of her. Cliff Martinez's gamelan-flavoured score is hypnotic, and the cutting between past and present sex scenes leaves you unsure what's real. Watched now, Kelvin, a controlling psychiatrist who walks out on a suicidal wife, is much harder to like than Clooney's charm suggests. The doppelgänger twist and the line "everything we've done is forgiven" feel like Hollywood bolt-ons. It reportedly got an F CinemaScore from opening-night audiences who expected Titanic in space.
All three of us set it free, and so did most of the patrons. Dan prefers it to the Tarkovsky, and so does Conrad.
It's a very evocative film, and it does scratch that itch I have for derelict spacecraft or space station investigations and grand existential, terrifying, cosmic, philosophical questions.
Conrad Hot take, very hot take. I think I prefer it to the Tarkovsky version.
Dan I think there's a lot to like. I think it's worth seeing.
Alex Heeney
Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.



