← The archive
Episode No.206

Seconds (1966)

with Lexi Amoriello

Directed by John Frankenheimer. Starring Rock Hudson, John Randolph, Jeff Corey, Salome Jens.

HorrorSci-fiGuest: Lexi Amoriello (Critics & Creators)
Seconds (with Lexi Amoriello)

1 September 2026 · 1:17:18

Lexi Amoriello, creator of Movie Recs by Lex, visits the Oubliette and returns with Seconds – made in 1966 by John Frankenheimer, fresh off the Cold War fever dreams of The Manchurian Candidate and Seven Days in May, and here pairing up with the great James Wong Howe for one last, extraordinary black-and-white swan song apiece. Seconds is the sort of film that genre fans tend to discover a decade after everyone insists it was always a classic, largely because it wasn't: it was booed at Cannes, quietly dumped by Paramount, and left to rot for 30 years before Criterion and the National Film Registry got around to correcting the record. Adapted by Lewis John Carlino from David Ely's 1963 novel, it asks a disarmingly simple question: what if you could buy a second life, no strings attached? With a truly game Rock Hudson doing career-best work as the walking punchline to that question, the film spends the rest of its runtime methodically proving that there is, in fact, always a string attached. But does it deserve a second chance beyond the Oubliette? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

Lexi Amoriello of Movie Rex by Lex joined us with a film that neither of us had seen and that she can't understand why more people haven't.

Arthur Hamilton (John Randolph) is a middle-aged banker with a comfortable marriage and a grown daughter, and he's quietly miserable. A note slipped to him on a train, a phone call from a friend he thought was dead, and a trip through a meat-packing plant bring him to the Company, which fakes his death and remakes him, surgically and completely, as Tony Wilson (Rock Hudson), a painter with a Malibu beach house and a new life to fill.

It's the last of Frankenheimer's paranoia trilogy, after The Manchurian Candidate and Seven Days in May, and it feels decades ahead of its time. The Substance, Severance, Get Out and The Game all seem to owe it something. James Wong Howe's Oscar-nominated photography straps the camera to actors, warps rooms with fish-eye lenses and crowds every frame, so the film never once lets you relax. Saul Bass's melting-face titles and Jerry Goldsmith's sparse, unresolved organ and string score add to the unease. The drill on the soundtrack is horrible. Hudson is a revelation, and Conrad reads the casting of Hollywood's most famous closeted star as a man trapped in a manufactured life as more than a coincidence. Hamilton's return to his wife, who calmly explains that her husband was dead long before they found his body, is devastating. The middle sags with two long parties and a naked grape-stomping bacchanal, and the ending is as bleak as 1966 got.

All three of us set it free. Not every patron was won over, but most were.

  • Thematically, I think this is probably one of the most interesting films that we've discovered, thanks to our guest, on this show.
    Conrad
  • This movie should be watched immediately by everyone.
    Dan
  • This is like absolutely his masterpiece in my mind.
    Lexi Amoriello

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.