← The archive
Episode No.062

Screamers (1995)

Directed by Christian Duguay. Starring Peter WellerRegular, Roy Dupuis, Jennifer Rubin, Andrew Lauer.

HorrorSci-fi
Screamers

28 September 2020 · 1:11:24

Conrad and Dan try not to get deja-vu as they watch a rag-tag bunch of futuristic soldiers on an alien planet battling bio-mechanical monsters, discovering a pre-pubescent kid clutching a toy is the only survivor, and getting to the escape ship only to realise there's one more monster to kill! No, it isn't Aliens – it's Screamers (1995). It stars Peter Weller as a grizzled philosophical man of war, Jennifer Rubin as a black market trader who greets people by stripping and sponge-bathing in front of them, and Andy Lauer as a solider called 'Ace'. Based on a Philip K. Dick story and a screenplay by Alien co-writer Dan O'Bannon, this has a serious pedigree – but should it be allowed aboard the escape ship or should it be eviscerated by semi-autonomous buzzsaws?

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictThrown back

Philip K. Dick's short story Second Variety, adapted by Dan O'Bannon and Miguel Tejada-Flores, gives this one a sturdier foundation than most of the direct-to-video Aliens imitators that followed in James Cameron's wake. On the radiation-blasted planet Sirius 6B, a decade-long war between a mining company and the Alliance has left a wasteland patrolled by the Screamers, burrowing mechanical killers that have started taking new forms. Peter Weller leads a small party across the wasteland to negotiate peace, as it dawns on them that the machines can now pass for human. The locations are impressive, turning the same landscape into snowfield one minute and desert the next, and the film does take some time over its characters.

The trouble is the twists. Every reveal of another robot breaks the rules established by the last, until the revelations stop meaning anything, and the robots keep exposing themselves in situations where staying hidden would have been far more effective. Then comes the final shot, which leaves a three-inch teddy bear as the gravest threat to humanity's future. It's a film whose ending sends you out laughing, and not on purpose. We agreed that the source material deserves another crack, and that this isn't it.

  • If they were going for B-grade, I wish they'd just dialled up the gore by 300%. It would have been so much fun. This version of his story, I hate to say it, but I was mostly bored.
    Dan
  • It just felt as though it went on too long. The logic broke down for me: the never-ending sequence of people revealing themselves to be robots in ways that they didn't need to, and they would have been more successful if they hadn't.
    Conrad

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.