← The archive
Episode No.019

Return to Oz (1985)

Directed by Walter Murch. Starring Fairuza Balk, Nicol Williamson, Jean Marsh, Piper Laurie.

Fantasy
Return to Oz

21 January 2019 · 1:15:14

Dan and Conrad Return... to Oz! Disney's belated and berated sequel to the beloved musical classic bombed in 1985, but does it deserve a re-evaluation?

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

Walter Murch's only directing credit, and one of the strangest studio sequels ever greenlit: Dorothy (Fairuza Balk, aged nine, later of The Craft and Almost Famous) is scheduled for electroshock therapy to cure her of talking about Oz, escapes into a storm, and returns to find the Emerald City in ruins under the rule of a witch who collects severed heads and a Nome King turning everything to stone. It shares almost nothing with the 1939 musical's tone: no songs, no primary-colour exuberance, just a muted, melancholy, genuinely unsettling children's film that treats loss and institutional cruelty as seriously as anything in the story. The budget was slashed before filming started, and it shows outdoors, but the interiors, particularly Mombi's palace, are gorgeous, and the puppetry and practical effects carry scenes that could easily have collapsed.

We landed in different places on how much that darkness works for the film rather than against it. One of us counts it among a handful of true childhood favourites, drawn specifically to everything that makes it the tonal opposite of the original. The other enjoyed real stretches of it, particularly the character work, but found the shakier effects and uneven pacing kept it from fully landing, voting to set it free while admitting to some real reservations.

  • I like it just enough to set it free. I can't put my finger on it, but something just doesn't quite work for me.
    Dan
  • I find the unremitting cheerfulness and primary colours of the classic original film just makes me gag. A film shot through with melancholy and loss, with a nine-year-old girl being threatened with electric shock therapy, is just my kind of bag.
    Conrad

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.