← The archive
Episode No.067

One Magic Christmas (1985)

featuring Elisabeth Harnois

Directed by Phillip Borsos. Starring Mary Steenburgen, Gary Basaraba, Harry Dean Stanton, Arthur Hill.

FantasyGuest: Elisabeth Harnois (Filmmakers)
One Magic Christmas (featuring Elisabeth Harnois)

7 December 2020 · 1:17:44

To get a bit of festive cheer, Dan and Conrad explore Disney's One Magic Christmas, which celebrates its 35th anniversary this year. But this is from Disney's 'dark period', so they're in for a shock. A harmonica-playing stalking angel played by Harry Dean Stanton teaches depressed working mum Ginnie Grainger (Mary Steenburgen) to appreciate the holiday season by forcing her to live a nightmarish alternate Christmas Eve in which her whole family is slaughtered in a bungled bank robbery. We kid you not. For all that, it turns out to be one of Conrad's favourite Christmas movies, and has a social realism and heartwarming message that marks it out from your standard Hallmark special. It also features some stellar performances, including that of special guest Elisabeth Harnois, who shares her memories of playing little Abbie Grainger at the tender age of 5! The result is – dare we say it – quite magical! Happy holidays!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

Conrad's family watch Phillip Borsos's 1985 Disney film every year, so this was always going to be a defence. Ginny Granger (Mary Steenburgen) has lost her Christmas spirit: her husband (Gary Basaraba) is out of work, the family has to leave the company house, and her checkout job comes with a bullying manager. So Santa dispatches Gideon (Harry Dean Stanton), a harmonica-playing angel, who shows her what she has by taking it all away in one brutal Christmas Eve. Conrad also got to interview Elisabeth Harnois, who played little Abby at the age of five and still believed in Santa throughout the shoot.

It's a rare Christmas film about a working-class family in Reagan's America, in a messy house with one bathroom, and it treats their troubles with unusual realism. Harnois and Steenburgen are wonderful, and Borsos keeps the camera locked on Ginny through her nightmare. Dan wasn't sold on the angel, who looks less like a bringer of festive cheer than a man you'd cross the road to avoid, or on a Santa who turns out to be a forgetful old man with a workshop full of pensioners. Even so, he admired a film that doesn't solve everything with a windfall, and found that the hope it offers is about giving what you can.

Both of us set it free.

  • Even the North Pole was staffed by old people. I mean, how boring is that? Where are the elves?
    Dan
  • I was the kind of kid that used to watch He-Man and wish that Skeletor would win one week. I was a dark kid.
    Conrad
  • They said each one of these snow globes is $5,000, and we only have five for the whole movie. So the point is, out of five, I only broke two.
    Elisabeth Harnois

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.