← The archive
Episode No.155

Equilibrium (2002)

Directed by Kurt Wimmer. Starring Christian Bale, Emily Watson, Taye Diggs, Angus Macfadyen.

Sci-fi
Equilibrium

29 July 2024 · 1:14:22

Christian Bale backflipped out of the oubliette dual-toting pistols, so we're forced to contend with Kurt Wimmer's Equilibrium (2002) – a sci-fi action extravaganza set in a totalitarian state where everyone has to complete the Kolinahr ritual and avoid content creation of any kind. Also starring Emily Watson, Taye Diggs and Sean Bea (although, of course, not for long), the film faceplanted on its release in December 2002 and has been dismissed as a lukewarm second serving of The Matrix (1999) ever since. Does everyone need to take a chill pill and appreciate this high-concept actioner for what it is? Or was everyone right first time? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

Patron Film Aficionado's pick, and a dividing line between the two of us. Dan watched it at 19 with a film student friend and loved it. Conrad remembers it as a Matrix knock-off championed by people he didn't get on with.

After World War III, the city-state of Libria abolishes emotion. Citizens dose themselves with Prozium, art and music are incinerated, and Grammaton Clerics hunt down "sense offenders", a phrase Dan couldn't stop hearing as something else entirely. Christian Bale's top cleric, John Preston, executes his partner (Sean Bean, dead in 18 minutes, which may be a personal best), misses a dose, and starts feeling things, with help from Emily Watson's doomed Mary and Beethoven.

Kurt Wimmer insists his influences were 1984, Fahrenheit 451 and THX 1138 rather than The Matrix. Shot in Berlin's brutalist leftovers for about $20 million, it looks far grander than it cost, and Mary's execution, staged like a witch burning, lands. Everything else rests on gun kata, Wimmer's backyard invention, in which Bale windmills his arms through 130-odd faceless henchmen without a scratch. Dan finds it impressive but stakes-free. Conrad found it inches from Hot Fuzz parody, and was unimpressed by the gun fetishism or the commentary claim that action is "how men express romance on film". The deeper problem is the premise: a drama about people who feel nothing, populated by ambitious, jealous, bickering characters.

Klaus Badelt's score is wall-to-wall plastic choir, and the best joke is Bale, all cheekbones, rising out of frame clutching a puppy.

Conrad threw it back. Dan, nostalgia goggles on, set it free, and the patrons voted 80 to 20 with him.

  • I know it's flawed. I know it's silly. I know the premise is outrageous. But I kind of still like it.
    Dan
  • You can't have a drama about people that don't feel anything.
    Conrad

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.