← The archive
Episode No.035

Enemy Mine (1985)

Directed by Wolfgang Petersen. Starring Dennis QuaidRegular, Louis Gossett Jr., Brion James, Richard Marcus.

Sci-fi
Enemy Mine

3 September 2019 · 1:05:40

Dan and Conrad are stranded on an alien planet with Dennis Quaid, Louis Gossett Jr. and some remote control turtles. Yes, it's Wolfgang Petersen's 80s sci-fi epic Enemy Mine. Will they learn to get along to survive? Or will they get dragged into what looks suspiciously like the sarlacc pit?

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

A troubled production if ever there was one: shot for two months in Iceland under director Richard Loncraine, scrapped entirely by 20th Century Fox, then rebuilt from scratch in Bavaria under Wolfgang Petersen fresh off The NeverEnding Story. What survives is a two-hander: Dennis Quaid's hot-shot pilot and Louis Gossett Jr.'s reptilian Drac soldier, marooned together on a hostile planet, forced from mutual hatred into something like family once Gossett's character dies and Quaid is left raising his child alone. Gossett invented an entire alien culture, physicality and vocal style from scratch, and it's a genuinely committed piece of work under Chris Walas's makeup.

We split hard on this one. One of us found Quaid's performance among his best and the film criminally underrated, undone only by a rushed final act. The other found the alien design uncanny-valley off-putting rather than endearing, the pacing sluggish by half an hour, and the themes of colonialism and prejudice gestured at rather than dug into. The coin of fate settled it in favour of freedom.

  • I felt like this could have been a great, concise Star Trek episode. But this movie just smears it out to an hour and 48 minutes, and it just felt like it dragged a lot.
    Dan
  • I think Dennis Quaid does an amazing job of going from this alpha male all the way through to grudging respect and then becoming a responsible parent and a better human being.
    Conrad

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.