Dune (1984)
Directed by David Lynch. Starring Kyle MacLachlan, Francesca Annis, Kenneth McMillan, Sting.

The spice must flow! And we have a feeling all kinds of spices were flowing during the making of Dune (1984), David Lynch's first faltering steps into the Hollywood mainstream. An ambitious attempt to realise Frank Herbert's seminal science fiction novel as a baroque, epic, intelligent, space opera, blockbuster yielded some indelible images – Sting naked except for a winged codpiece springs to mind – and flounders in the uncanny valley between a true Lynchian vision of a world some 8000 years in the future and a cleansed, PG-rated family film for the cinemagoing masses. The result is fascinating and curious – not least for having a jaw-dropping cast – but, crucially, does it deserve to leave the oubliette on its 40th anniversary? Or should it be left as a footnote in the great director's career, its memory erased in favour of Denis Villeneuve's box office smash hit remakes? Find out!
Did we set it free?
Make your call to reveal our verdict, our star rating out of five and our full review.
Skip the guess and read the review
VerdictThrown back
With Villeneuve's Part Two arriving in cinemas, we finally tackled David Lynch's only real blockbuster. Dan came armed with the novel and its sequel; Conrad came armed with childhood memories of a film he found grand, slow and baffling on VHS.
The first 40 minutes won Dan over. Then the film starts skipping chapters. Paul and Chani fall in love between scenes, Jessica goes from Bene Gesserit powerhouse to bystander, Max von Sydow and Patrick Stewart (who charges into battle clutching a pug) barely register, and Sting's Feyd-Rautha gets a handful of lines and a winged codpiece. Holding it together is a torrent of whispered internal monologue so redundant that Paul thinks "it's under control" as we watch him regain control. Dan reckons it might as well be an audiobook. The Harkonnens, whom Lynch reportedly most enjoyed filming, are so pustular and glistening that they play as buffoons rather than villains, and the weirding modules, Lynch's own invention, turn every battle into lethal throat singing.
And yet. The production design is astonishing: baroque golden spaceships, superb practical miniatures, the Guild Navigator in its tank, the Gom Jabbar test and the Hunter Seeker sequence, all shot by Freddie Francis and scored by Toto, with a prophecy theme from Brian Eno. The optical effects, on the other hand, are dreadful, and the personal shields look like animated cardboard boxes.
The patrons voted 92 to 8 to set it free, and we overruled them. Conrad's rationale, a half-arsed one by his own admission, is that this simply isn't the film Lynch wanted to make. Memorable and influential, but it doesn't work as drama.
It's awful to the point where we may as well just turn it into an audiobook.
Dan It's distinct and astonishing and just a feast to look at, and weird and powerful in odd ways. But it doesn't work as a narrative or as a drama.
Conrad
Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.




