← The archive
Episode No.026

Disturbing Behavior (1998)

Directed by David Nutter. Starring James Marsden, Katie Holmes, Nick Stahl, Bruce Greenwood.

HorrorSci-fi
Disturbing Behavior

30 April 2019 · 1:09:35

Dan and Conrad review listener's choice 90s horror 'Disturbing Behavior', in which twentysomething teenager James Marsden moves to a new town and discovers a Stepford Wives-style conspiracy against delinquent high schoolers. With the help of his new friends, post-Dawson's Creek Katie Holmes and pre-Terminator Nick Stahl, can he avoid becoming one of the squeaky clean Blue Ribbon Group of 50s throwbacks?

Dan gets nostalgic over 90s grunge, while Conrad finds the most disturbing thing is the movie's spelling of the word 'behaviour'. Will they deem GoT veteran director David Nutter's first major movie worthy of release from the oubliette?

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictThrown back

A listener suggestion via the Ubliette Roulette: a family moves to a small island town where the popular kids have all suddenly become disturbingly perfect, and the new kid (James Marsden) starts uncovering a programme quietly lobotomising local teenagers into obedience. It's a premise with real teeth, adolescent conformity, entitlement, image, all ready to be mined the way Get Out or Heathers or Society mined their own satirical targets. David Nutter, an X-Files alum making his feature debut, was reportedly fighting the studio the entire way through, with character development cut every time he added it back in, and the finished film shows exactly that kind of damage: a great hook with almost nothing built around it.

What's left is a fairly hollow 90s artefact, competently soundtracked and cast (James Marsden, Katie Holmes, Nick Stahl all present and game) but never engaging with any of its own ideas past the surface. Neither of us found much to hold onto beyond pure period nostalgia, and even that only stretches so far for one of us who isn't especially sentimental about the decade. We agreed quickly and without much internal debate.

  • It's a film full of holes, full of 'I wish they'd done this' and 'maybe this character could have gone that way.' So much potential. I would love for this film to be remade, because the premise alone is interesting and intriguing.
    Dan
  • It just doesn't work on any level. It's not so-bad-it's-good, it's not satirical, it's not Heathers, it's not Society. It's just kind of a 90s pop-video soundtrack album selling thing that lasts for 80 minutes and doesn't engage me at all.
    Conrad

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.