← The archive
Episode No.187

Dead Birds (2004)

Directed by Alex Turner. Starring Henry Thomas, Nicki Aycox, Isaiah Washington, Patrick Fugit.

Horror
Dead Birds

18 November 2025 · 1:11:59

Dead Birds (2004), directed by Alex Turner and produced during the early-2000s boom in grimy, low-budget horror, is a Confederate-era ghost story that alternates between jump scares for a slow rot of dread and bad decisions. It follows a group of Civil War deserters – played by E.T.'s Henry Thomas, Patrick Fugit, Michael Shannon, and Isaiah Washington – who rob a bank and hole up in a derelict plantation, only to discover it’s crawling with the supernatural consequences of its own bloody past! So should this dusty relic be set free at last or should it be trapped in the dark with its guilt? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictThrown back

Patron Arctic Dipper nominated this horror western, and it was new to both of us. Horror westerns are thin on the ground, so we went in hopeful.

In 1863 Alabama, a gang of Confederate deserters and outlaws rob a bank, leaving a pile of bodies, a child among them. Henry Thomas's William leads them, with Patrick Fugit as his younger brother Sam, Nicki Aycox as his lover Annabelle, Isaiah Washington as Todd, an escaped slave, and Michael Shannon and Mark Boone Junior as the pair nobody trusts. On the way to Mexico they hole up in an abandoned plantation house, ignoring a corpse-like scarecrow, a hairless white creature they've just shot dead and a locked cellar with noises behind it.

It's an early script by Simon Barrett, later of You're Next and The Guest, and the craft is real. The town in the opening robbery is the set from Tim Burton's Big Fish, borrowed for a film reportedly made for under $1.5 million. The locations are handsome, and a practical disembowelment in the cellar is horribly effective. The trouble is everything else. The film can't decide whether it's a creature feature, a ghost story or a tale of an owner who sacrificed his slaves to resurrect his wife and got demon children instead, so it does all three, explained through convenient exposition dumps. Jump scares arrive every couple of minutes, often in flash-frame CGI that now looks dated. The making-of shows meddling producers, and the director and writer say on the commentary that they hated the line naming the Book of the Dead. Peter Lopez's score is relentless, all room tone and clang. Even the title is a leftover from a cut shot.

We both threw it back, and the patrons agreed. Sorry, Arctic Dipper.

  • If you've never seen a horror movie in your life, this might be okay. But if you've seen horror movies, this is just cliche overload.
    Dan
  • I think it's okay, but I think it's just okay.
    Conrad

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.