Black Christmas (1974)
with Kelli Maroney
Directed by Bob Clark. Starring Olivia Hussey, Keir Dullea, Margot Kidder, John Saxon.

Kelli Maroney, star of Chopping Mall and Night of the Comet, joins us for a festive retrospective review of the first horror movie she saw in a theater: Black Christmas! The original 1974 slasher thriller has everything you want in seasonal cinema: screaming prank phone calls, unicorn stabbings and plastic bag suffocations! But does it deserve to be rescued from relative obscurity?
Did we set it free?
Make your call to reveal our verdict, our star rating out of five and our full review.
Skip the guess and read the review
VerdictSet free
Our Christmas episode came with a gift: Kelli Maroney, Night of the Comet's Sam Belmont, who picked the first horror film she ever saw in a cinema. Bob Clark's 1974 film sends an obscene caller, and then a killer, into a sorority house over the Christmas break, and it got there four years before Halloween. Kelli had it that Clark himself suggested to John Carpenter that a sequel might move to another holiday. The second shot is already the killer's point of view, and Albert J. Dunk's roving, harness-mounted camera never lets you settle on where he is. Instead of jump scares there's dread, a score of scraped piano strings from Carl Zittrer, and an ending that holds on the house while the phone rings on through the credits.
What surprised us most was how much we liked the victims. Margot Kidder's foul-mouthed Barb, Marian Waldman's bottle-hiding house mother, and Olivia Hussey's Jess, telling Keir Dullea she won't be keeping the baby in a film shot the year Roe v. Wade was decided, all get the kind of attention later slashers never bothered with, which makes every death land harder. Jess still heads back up the stairs instead of out of the front door, but the genre has far worse to answer for. Unanimous: set free, and nobody should bother with the 2006 remake.
By the end of watching this film, I just felt really icky, like I need to take a shower or something.
Dan If you think Halloween is the source of all great slasher movies, you're wrong. Take a few steps backwards in time and watch Bob Clark's classic, because you get to see everything that John Carpenter picked up on.
Conrad There's such a buildup. There's such a thing about Christmas, Christmas, Christmas. It's so much pressure. There's so much family stuff going on. Horror lives to build tension and then release it all at once.
Kelli Maroney
Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.




