← The archive
Episode No.009

The Stuff (1985)

Directed by Larry Cohen. Starring Michael Moriarty, Andrea Marcovicci, Garrett Morris, Paul Sorvino.

Horror
The Stuff

4 September 2018 · 1:15:00

Conrad and Dan find The Stuff (1985) oozing out of the oubliette. Will they get addicted to Larry Cohen's evil dessert, which threatens to enslave America? Or is enough really enough?

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictThrown back

A double-blind pick, neither of us having seen it before: a sweet, addictive, calorie-free dessert oozes out of the ground in Georgia and becomes a national craze before anyone realises it's slowly turning everyone who eats it into a hollowed-out zombie host. Larry Cohen's premise is genuinely great, corporate America selling the public a consumable monster, but the execution never settles on what it wants to be. It isn't tense enough to work as horror, and it's too muddled about what it's actually satirising, junk food, advertising, Reagan-era consumerism, all three at once, to land as satire either. Characters get introduced with a habit or a quirk and then vanish for the rest of the runtime; plot points get shoehorned in on the day and never followed up.

There are things to admire in isolation: some genuinely inventive practical effects, and a scrappy, improvisational energy that suggests Cohen having fun even when the film around him isn't working. But scene after scene of over-explained dialogue, undercut further by ADR patching in things that still didn't make sense, wore us both down. We agreed fast and without much regret.

  • There were so many characters that were introduced and never seen again. Even trait-wise, like Nicole always cracking her bones for no reason at all. A lot of elements you could tell Larry Cohen had just come up with on the day and told actors to do.
    Dan
  • I found it very difficult to enjoy as a story. I found it difficult to enjoy as a satire because I really didn't know what he was satirising. It's a great concept, but he can never settle on one approach to how he's going to use it.
    Conrad

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.