← The archive
Episode No.183

The One I Love (2014)

with Isaac Sutton

Directed by Charlie McDowell. Starring Mark Duplass, Elisabeth Moss, Ted Danson.

HorrorGuest: Isaac Sutton (Critics & Creators)
The One I Love (with Isaac Sutton)

23 September 2025 · 1:10:07

Isaac Sutton takes on guest hosting duties with Dan to explore Charlie McDowell's The One I Love (2014) – an offbeat romantic mystery starring Mark Duplass and Elisabeth Moss, with the director's step-dad, Ted Danson, in a small but pivotal role. Shot largely at a single location over 15 days, it follows a troubled married couple who retreat to a secluded estate for therapy — only to discover a bizarre phenomenon that presents them with eerily perfect duplicates of themselves. As the surreal premise deepens, the boundaries between love, identity, and self-delusion begin to unravel. Should it be hailed as a clever indie gem about self-acceptance, or quietly left to vanish like a partner who didn’t make it out of the Twilight Zone?

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

With Conrad at TIFF, executive producer Isaac Sutton returned to pick a film he first saw as a Sundance-obsessed high-school senior. It was a first watch for Dan.

Ethan (Mark Duplass) and Sophie (Elisabeth Moss) have a marriage in trouble, and their therapist (Ted Danson) sends them for a weekend at a secluded house. In the guest house, each finds an idealised version of their spouse: a Sophie who cooks Ethan bacon and does whatever he says, and an Ethan without glasses who listens, does push-ups and says the right thing. Sophie wants to live in the fantasy; Ethan wants to know what on earth is going on.

McDowell's debut, shot from a structural outline with much of the dialogue improvised, runs on Duplass and Moss, who play four distinct people with tiny, precise differences, and the split-screen effects are seamless. Their sniping feels painfully real, and a late confrontation between the two Sophies about what she really fears losing cuts deep. The film loses its way when it explains itself. A conveniently placed computer of recordings reveals the doubles are another couple, trained to take their places, which raises more questions than it answers: where they hide, how they know so much, what happened to the bacon. The deceptions behind the bedroom scenes sit uneasily too. Danny Bensi and Saunder Jurriaans's chamber score, all clarinet and celeste, recalls Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind. The ending leaves it open which Sophie Ethan is with, and Dan and Isaac read it differently.

Both set it free, as did 67 per cent of the patrons. Jasmine was not among them. Back from Toronto, Conrad called it a true Oubliette gem.

  • You can't have an Ethan mindset with it. You have to have a Sophie mindset with it. You have to accept the fantasy.
    Dan
  • I think thematically and from a character perspective, it's so strong and so compelling that, like, it would be a shame for it to rot away in the Oubliette.
    Isaac Sutton
  • I really enjoyed it. I'd never heard of it before. So, yeah, it's a true Oubliette gem we've found there.
    Conrad

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.