← The archive
Episode No.090

Starman (1984)

Directed by John CarpenterRegular. Starring Jeff BridgesRegular, Karen Allen, Charles Martin Smith, Richard Jaeckel.

Sci-fi
Starman

15 November 2021 · 1:13:00

In a special Patrons' Choice episode, we take a look back at Starman (1984), John Carpenter's romantic sci-fi fable starring Jeff Bridges in an Oscar-nominated role as a visiting alien and Karen Allen as the widow whose husband he impersonates. Kicking off with a disturbing alien birth sequence that showcases the combined talents of Rick Baker, Stan Winston and Dick Smith (yes, you read that right), Starman shifts gears into a road movie with a fish-out-of-water comedy and an odd couple romance thrown into the mix. But does it hold up 37 years later? Does it point towards a more nuanced career for the 'Master of Horror' that was not to be? Or does it collapse under its disturbing abduction romance tropes and reliance on post-ET sentimentality? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

Patron Wicked Person's pick sent us to John Carpenter's least Carpenter-ish film, the one he made, by his own account, to apologise for The Thing.

An alien answers Voyager 2's invitation, is promptly shot down, and grows into a clone of Jenny Hayden's late husband Scott in a sequence that pooled the talents of Rick Baker, Stan Winston and Dick Smith. The first 20 minutes play like a horror film; the rest is a road movie, as Karen Allen drives this twitchy stranger towards a crater in Arizona.

Jeff Bridges earned an Oscar nomination for a performance built on a bird's movements and peculiar enunciation that slowly finds its feet, and Allen is wonderfully open and vulnerable. The deer scene had Conrad welling up. Columbia chose this over E.T., and it plays like E.T. for adults. Then come the questions. An alien wearing a grieving widow's dead husband falls in love with her, gets her pregnant, mentions afterwards that he could stop it if she likes, then flies home. Dan loved almost everything about it and still came away uneasy; Conrad finds it touching all the same. The supporting cast barely register, and Jack Nitzsche's synth theme is lovely. Set free, a little uncertainly.

  • Essentially, you've got an alien that's come to Earth, posed as someone's dead husband, impregnated her, and then fucked off back to his home planet.
    Dan
  • Starman is effectively E.T. for adults.
    Conrad

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.