← The archive
Episode No.070

My Bloody Valentine (1981)

Directed by George Mihalka. Starring Paul Kelman, Lori Hallier, Neil Affleck, Keith Knight.

Horror
My Bloody Valentine (1981)

10 February 2021 · 1:04:21

We're getting all romantic this week, in honour of Valentine's Day, and celebrating the 40th anniversary of the Canadian slasher 'My Bloody Valentine' – a film that vanished into a deep dark mine upon its release, possibly thanks to the heavy hand of the MPAA in the editing room. It features a mining town cursed by a legendary tragedy, Moosehead Beer and a returning killer who's a cross between Darth Vader, Michael Myers and the Cadbury Milk Tray Man. But does it deserve to be unearthed and recut into a gleaming diamond, or should it be tossed aside like a cheap box of chocolates?

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

A double blind for Valentine's Day, though it turned out we hadn't quite watched the same film. George Mihalka's 1981 Canadian slasher has a killer in a miner's gas mask stalking the mining town of Valentine Bluffs, 20 years after a disaster down the pit, leaving human hearts in chocolate boxes along with some very wonky poems. Conrad watched the restored version, with as much of the gore that the MPAA had trimmed away frame by frame put back in. Dan, it emerged mid-recording, had the original theatrical cut, in which nearly every kill cuts away before it lands.

It has real virtues. The young cast are working people in thrift-store knitwear rather than catwalk models, the love triangle has some depth, and the shoot in a genuine mine looks terrific. But the killer's motive makes no sense, the reveal is easy to spot (the actor worked it out himself when the effects team took a cast of his arm), the opening murder is never explained, and the scares land with a thud whichever cut you watch.

Dan had fun with it and voted to free it. Conrad couldn't see himself recommending it to anyone. The coin of fate came up heads, Dan's first win of the year, and it was set free.

  • The first time I watched it, the reveal at the end was a letdown. But re-watching it, I did have fun with it. And I really want to watch the uncut version now.
    Dan
  • I have to say, it left me cold, just as cold as a deep dark mine, to be honest.
    Conrad

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.